About 49,500 people took their own lives last year in the U.S., the highest number ever, according to new government data posted Thursday.

  • @Impassionata
    link
    English
    11 year ago

    And all (well, most) of that is well and good! But:

    I will reiterate again that using your trauma as an excuse to hold bigoted views is childish and that it shouldn’t be encouraged.

    All politics is trauma mitigation. And you don’t get to tell people that they should just not have their trauma, that they can not bring their trauma to the discussion table, because that isn’t actually mitigating the trauma, just suppressing it. Since trauma is experienced intersectionally the unpacking of that trauma necessarily occurs contra another intersection.

    If the contest is over who gets to unpack their trauma, you aren’t going to succeed at bringing everyone to the table by forcing one ideology (in this case, ‘feminism-for-everyone’) into a position that is untenably ‘omnivorous’ (because it contradicts with ‘feminism-for-women’).

    And there is this spectre in your thinking: there is no pure thought, there is no position free from bias, there is no exculpation you can perform to absolve yourself from contamination with the bigotry attendant upon trauma. You can’t ask someone who has been robbed at gunpoint by a Black person to be less afraid of Black neighborhoods, regardless of the hurtful bigotry of their acquired bias.

    As I heard it, you don’t get to have a place free of racism. You can only mitigate its destructive effects.

    Because of this, the online tendency to gather ideology into a perfect model rational reasonable list of beliefs is doomed.

    Guiding and directing policy are no different for someone who doesn’t hold office.

    I think this is plain wrong but I’m having difficulty articulating precisely why.