Hey y’all!

I’ve been using Authy for some time now (switched from Google Authenticator) but an increasing amount of people is suggesting Aegis over Authy in some posts here at Lemmy and that got me curious.

Was wondering what would be the main selling points for one to use Aegis instead of Authy, can somebody help out?

Thanks in advance!

  • Eager Eagle
    link
    English
    6
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    that way your OTPs are less secure

    Aegis backups are encrypted. One could argue that storing OTP seeds in someone else’s server is even less secure, which is what Authy does.

    because of security

    Yeah, I read that too when choosing OTP managers and I’m not convinced. These security reasons they give to practice vendor lock-in just sound very convenient to them. They could very well add a secure bidirectional data import/export functionality like Aegis does. If they are really concerned about account takeover, they can confirm user identity, add delays with notifications before exporting, or add any similar bureaucracy. But if password managers allow exporting entire vaults, an MFA app can allow the same for OTPs.

    And I insist on this feature because manually resetting over 40+ MFA codes that I have because there is no export feature is a REAL PITA.