I don’t know what a MHGA kid is, but assume that neither of us is one, so I don’t know why you’re basing your answers about what you think on what a group uninvolved in this conversation thinks.

And I think calling the current actions in Gaza genocide

Do you doubt the intent, the move toward genocide, or do we need to wait for every Palestinian to be killed? I think South Africa have made A pretty robust case in the ICJ.

Plus accusing the Israeli citizens who identify as Palestinians (read 21% of Israel’s population) of committing genocide of Palestinians is silly.

I’m accusing the state of Israel - the fact that an apartheid underclass exists isn’t the defence you think it is.

So your position on the genocide is that there isn’t one. What would a proportionate Palestinian response to Israel’s aggression look like?

If you’ve got issues with whatever the MHGA kids are, take it up with them - I don’t know who they are, and can’t speak for them.