• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    603 months ago

    This system is considered one of the most advanced and secretive in Russia’s defense arsenal. It works by emitting radio frequency (RF) interference disrupting the control signals between the drone and its operator, forcing it to either land or hover in place until it is brought down, or its battery fails.

    Am I reading this wrong, or, are they in fact saying that Russia’s most advanced defensive technology is an rf jammer?

    • @Ordo_Bellatores
      link
      English
      283 months ago

      Well compared to wood blocks and chicken wire cages, a simple RF hammer does seem pretty high tech …

    • peopleproblems
      link
      English
      153 months ago

      Given the massive distance these drones fly, I think an RF jammer is the best they could come up with.

      And it doesn’t appear to be very effective judging by the footage of drone attacks.

    • @Ansis100
      link
      English
      143 months ago

      Isn’t an RF jammer basically the only defense against a drone? Apart from shooting it down?

  • Skua
    link
    fedilink
    413 months ago

    Ukrainian military analyst Oleksandr Kovalenko commented that he believes the Volnorez system’s capability to be overstated, describing it as practically useless. He argues that it has been deployed on the battlefield for a year without significantly impacting on the success of the Armed Forces of Ukraine’s (AFU) kamikaze drone attacks.

    I know nothing about this guy’s credentials, but this was my first thought. I have seen so many tanks getting destroyed by drones. Are these systems not getting deployed or do they not work?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      223 months ago

      Probably a bit of both. I’m sure Russia has been overstating how many operational systems they have. “Appear strong when you are weak”, and all that. But claims and appearances only go so far.

      • @IphtashuFitz
        link
        English
        113 months ago

        It would not surprise me if this is mostly a placebo to calm the nerves of the tank crew.

    • mozz
      link
      fedilink
      13 months ago

      Presumably they don’t post the ones where it works and the drone crashes

      I suspect it is useless just because of the pace of technological development on the Ukraine side vs. the Russian side, but just the existence of some videos where the EW isn’t working doesn’t mean it’s not working.

  • @lemming741
    link
    English
    103 months ago

    Give the drone a few directional antennas and have it aim for the jammers

      • @werefreeatlast
        link
        English
        -33 months ago

        Cancer. All ruzzians driving these tanks are going to be getting cancer.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          63 months ago

          HARM is a category of weapon which seeks things like radar or jammers. They weren’t suggesting that the jammers are literally harmless.

          In unrelated news: the jammers are, in fact, harmless unless you’re making a habit of riding on top of the tank. The radio energy isn’t going to penetrate a significant thickness of conductive material, such as armour plating. Or unless you’re the person being jammed, in which case they’re a different category of harmful

          • @werefreeatlast
            link
            English
            -33 months ago

            Ionization is not the only way RF can affect the body. You can generate plasma at low RF energy that is not ionizing. Yet the plasma is bad for you. So if you can generate plasma in vacuum with non ionizing RF, imagine what it can do to anything it can couple to.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    93 months ago

    I was expecting this counter-drone system was destroyed by Ukrainian drones… but this is even better.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    53 months ago

    Wouldn’t you not want to tell them you have one so that they keep wasting energy and manpower thinking it works?

    • @Maalus
      link
      English
      103 months ago

      Or you tell them you have it and they immediately stop using it, even before you crack how it works.

  • @ChicoSuave
    link
    English
    23 months ago

    Look at that, a fantastic find! Even if Sudzha is retaken, the knowledge of Russian anti-drone tech is now revealed. And it’s so stupid. Like, is Russia undergoing an active internal rebellion to help make things worse? Because it’s hard to imagine any effort being so constantly countered - and so effectively!