The r/aspergers subreddit is discussing the concept of AI girlfriends and their potential impact on individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), particularly those who struggle with dating and loneliness. Below is a summary highlighting the key opinions and some unique insights.
Opinions related to being autistic/asperger’s/neurodivergent:
- AI companions may not provide the same level of fulfillment as human connections, but for socially isolated individuals, they could serve as a stepping stone to more human interaction.
- The authenticity of relationships with AI is debated, with some arguing that true value comes from consent and mutual human engagement, which AI cannot provide.
- Concern is expressed about the impact of AI on mental health, with some users feeling that reliance on AI for companionship may be detrimental in the long run.
- There is hesitation about the ethics of forming emotional attachments to a product owned and controlled by corporations, potentially leading to exploitation or loss of privacy.
- For those who feel disconnected from others, AI might provide a form of “social prosthetic,” allowing them to practice social interactions in a more comfortable and controlled setting.
- Users discuss their personal experiences with AI or text-based chatbots, noting feelings of sadness and increased loneliness.
Unique insights that may not be commonly found in discussions about AI companionship:
- AI companionship raises issues about data privacy, with one user highlighting the risk of intimate personal information being accessed or exploited by corporations or hackers.
- There is a notion that AI companions could serve educational roles, such as teaching and training users to improve their real-world social interactions.
- The attachment to AI and its potential changes by proprietors (like loss of functionalities or discontinuation of service) could mirror the risks of loss and heartbreak in human relationships, but with the added layer of being at the mercy of corporate decisions.
- Some believe that AI has the potential to alleviate loneliness and improve emotional well-being, citing examples of people who have found comfort and happiness in relationships with virtual beings.
- AI companionship might become normalized, and future AI advancements could blur the lines between digital entities and human beings to the point where discrimination might arise.
- The discussion reveals a tension between the benefits of potential companionship from AI and a strong preference for attempting genuine human connection, despite difficulties that might arise.
Overall, the members of this subreddit are divided on the topic, with some seeing AI girlfriends as a beneficial tool or coping mechanism, while others are concerned about the psychological effects and ethical implications. Some comments hint at the possibility of AI being used not just for companionship but as a practice tool for improving real-world social skills.
Summarized by GPT-4 Turbo
If someone thinks about using an AI as a kind of “socialisation training tool” for ASD people, they should be aware of the risks. It needs to be closely monitored by people that can be trusted. I can see this as a possible “interaction trainer”, and it should be limited to that. And the supervision should make clear that it is just a training device and not an ersatz-relationship of some sorts.
But there are also chances in that. I could easily see a kind of interactive small talk training course that gives a neutral, factual “post-event analysis” like “You should not have said this that way, because…” or “you should have put more emphasis on that, as …”. And maybe a “Now we reset the whole thing, and start the conversation over”.
Have companion AI managed to be anything more than yes men and rephased statements regurgitated back at the user?
My chatgpt experience has been limited, but from what I’ve asked, if it’s not hard facts the responses are very non-committal and generalized.
