The first one, “Space Babies” was alright, but felt too childish. “The Devils Chord” didn’t hit for me because they just didn’t have the budget for really being able to explore a higher level being of such power.

But Boom? Boom can be defeated by one simple question. “Where’s the Sonic?”

It’s never addressed, the Doctor never asks Ruby to go get it from the TARDIS if he doesn’t have it on him. And it’s never even explained that if she could go and get it, it wouldn’t effect the landmine.

It’s basic questions like this, that need to be answered in an episode like this. It would have taken a total of 4 sentences to cancel out the Sonic. But they never even mention it.

That’s just bad writing right there.

Plus the Doctor’s dialogue felt like it belonged more to Matt’s Doctor than Ncuti’s and DEAR GOD, Moffat cannot write children to save his life.

I’m hoping the season gets better because they’re 1.5 for three with me right now.

  • @Lemming421
    link
    English
    84 months ago

    I thought he was going to sonic the mine and get on with the episode, but when I realised where things were going, the answer is simple - the sonic was in his pocket, but he couldn’t move to get it (or get Ruby to retrieve it) because that would shift his weight too much and set the mine off.

    • @Alpha71OP
      link
      English
      64 months ago

      He couldn’t reach into his pocket, yet he could catch a compressed flesh tube?

      • @jordanlund
        link
        English
        64 months ago

        He caught the compressed flesh tube to off-set putting his other foot down.

        If the sonic is in his pocket, there’s no compensation.

        • @Alpha71OP
          link
          English
          34 months ago

          fair enough of an explanation, but again… They didn’t say any of that

          • @jordanlund
            link
            English
            64 months ago

            They did explicitly explain the catching of the tube with putting the foot down though.

            Although how funny would it have been to make him do the episode on one foot? ;)

            • @Alpha71OP
              link
              English
              34 months ago

              But it doesn’t explain the sonic.