• Corgana
    link
    fedilink
    106 months ago

    AI-generated alt-text for images in PDFs: Oh fuck right off.

    Why is this bad?

    • kbal
      link
      fedilink
      -6
      edit-2
      6 months ago

      I kind of resent having a pdf editor in my web browser at all. Putting a giant LLM-based image classifier in there seems inadvisable even if it was going to do something more useful than suggest alt text for images you add to pdfs.

      Accessibility tools that can describe images, as well as pdf editing, are fine things for Mozilla to work on but they really shouldn’t be done as part of Firefox alone. Image describing has way more uses than just what’s found in the web browser, and should be a system-wide thing. There’s no point in each application having its own. Doing it only for things inserted into pdfs compounds the absurdity. If the accessibility APIs that exist can’t handle it, it’s time to propose a better one — and maybe go ahead and implement it on Linux. Solving the problem properly would be a more ambitious goal, but one that seems appropriate for an organization with the stature of Mozilla.

      • katy ✨
        link
        fedilink
        96 months ago

        I kind of resent having a pdf editor in my web browser at all.

        gonna assume it’s for the pdf reader, considering that’s where alt text in images is needed.