• AbsentBird
    link
    fedilink
    46 months ago

    There were many brave and accomplished citizens of allied nations who refused military service and who were integral to victory over the axis.

    Alan Turing broke the German cyphers and was staunchly antiwar. Howard Florey won the nobel prize for the mass production of penicillin and rejected military rank. Einstein himself was an outspoken pacifist, but it was his research that made the atomic bomb possible.

    If the allies had been as interested in forcing everyone into military service as the axis, it’s likely the war would have been even more bloody and prolonged.

    • @PugJesus
      link
      English
      8
      edit-2
      6 months ago

      There were many brave and accomplished citizens of allied nations who refused military service and who were integral to victory over the axis.

      Alan Turing

      … didn’t refuse wartime service. The exact opposite, in fact. You… you do realize not all military service is shooting guns, right? Turing’s work was directly related to discovering German movements, and then, killing them. The Brits weren’t codebreaking to find out the Nazis’ favorite color for a Valentine’s day card.

      Howard Florey won the nobel prize for the mass production of penicillin and rejected military rank.

      … okay?

      Einstein himself was an outspoken pacifist, but it was his research that made the atomic bomb possible.

      If the allies had been as interested in forcing everyone into military service as the axis, it’s likely the war would have been even more bloody and prolonged.

      Well, I am glad you agree that the atomic bombs saved many lives, at least.

      • AbsentBird
        link
        fedilink
        -16 months ago

        Alan Turing didn’t refuse wartime service.

        He was part of the anti-war movement while attending Cambridge. By your reasoning Gandhi was part of the military because he volunteered as a medic. Turing was not a soldier.

        • @PugJesus
          link
          English
          26 months ago

          He was part of the anti-war movement while attending Cambridge.

          … okay? Your argument is then because at the age of 21, near a decade before WW2, he was part of an anti-war movement when in college; therefore, he was a total pacifist and his willing and eager service to military intelligence at the outbreak of WW2 against one of the most vile governments in modern history ‘didn’t count’?

          By your reasoning Gandhi was part of the military because he volunteered as a medic.

          When was this? The only military service I remember Gandhi being a part of was pre-WW2, and in those cases, quite decidedly in support of a brutal imperial British machine.

          • AbsentBird
            link
            fedilink
            06 months ago

            Turing was never a pacifist, but he was anti-war. He probably saw his work in signal intelligence as important to ending the war.

            • @PugJesus
              link
              English
              16 months ago

              Oh, cool, then Eisenhower was also anti-war.

              • AbsentBird
                link
                fedilink
                0
                edit-2
                6 months ago

                Eisenhower was a soldier, he served in the 19th infantry regiment. Turing wasn’t a soldier.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      36 months ago

      Alan Turing broke the German cyphers and was staunchly antiwar.

      Are you confusing correlation with causation?

      • AbsentBird
        link
        fedilink
        06 months ago

        He was part of the anti-war student movement at Cambridge in 1933.