As the shift away from fossil fuels gathers pace, the Coalition has turned to an emissions-free technology with a long and contentious history — nuclear fission. These are the numbers you should keep in mind when thinking about its place in Australia’s energy transition.

I encourage you to at least glance through the article before you leave a comment that other commenters will dunk on you for.

  • Norah - She/They
    link
    fedilink
    English
    -16 months ago

    …pumped hydro is cheaper.

    It might be cheaper financially, but we’ve known about the huge environmental cost of dams for decades now. It boggles my mind that people suggest it in the same sentence as renewables.

    Let alone that the immediate risk to life and property if a dam bursts can be similar to that of a nuclear meltdown.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      46 months ago

      We are talking in the Australian context where the dams were built in the '50s for hydro power.

      • Norah - She/They
        link
        fedilink
        English
        06 months ago

        And? We should be decommissioning and demolishing any that are upstream of settlements because of their huge risk of catastrophe.

        • Zagorath
          link
          fedilink
          English
          56 months ago

          because of their huge risk of catastrophe

          Dams help prevent natural disasters. Preventing flooding is famously why the Aswan High Dam was built in Egypt, and the presence of flood-managed dams in SEQ is possibly one of the reasons we were affected so much less badly here in 2022 than Northern NSW, where the dams are comparatively small, ungated, and have no active management during flood conditions.

          I agree that dams are not great ecologically and we should avoid building them, especially given how incredibly useful solar and wind power are (though wind has its own ecological problems). But it’s not especially useful to say that they have a “huge risk of catastrophe”.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            26 months ago

            There are a class of American privately owned dams that recently got press for being at risk of catastrophe. I think that’s what informed that lemming

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          16 months ago

          Just take them down? With what people paid with what money? Keep in mind that these dams are our best black start capability, that they have important use

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      26 months ago

      Pumped hydro is not exactly a dam. There’s a hole and 2 water reservoirs. Yes there’s a cost but so does anything.