• @btaf45
    link
    75 months ago

    Every penny they make is taxed to Uncle Sam

    There is no where near a 100% income tax rate LMFAO. Obviously nonsense claims do not make a good argument.

    If he campaigns on this,

    MAKE INFLATION GREAT AGAIN

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      3
      edit-2
      5 months ago

      I think they mean they tax based on their total income not they collect the entire income

      Canada does the same thing for people abroad

      • @btaf45
        link
        15 months ago

        Marginal tax rates are based on adjusted gross income, type of income, and amount of income. Common adjustments include tax credits, tax free income adjustments, and deductions.

          • @btaf45
            link
            15 months ago

            Even if he meant that his hyperbole is still wrong. Every penny is not taken into account since all amounts are rounding to the nearest dollar.

          • @Cryophilia
            link
            15 months ago

            No they don’t. The standard exemption for fiscal year 2024 is $14,600 for every single filer, regardless of total income. The first $14,600 is literally not taxed.

            There’s also many credits that do not take income into account at all.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              25 months ago

              Brackets are how your total income is broken up. Your total income is still relevant so they know when to stop taxing

              • @Cryophilia
                link
                15 months ago

                That’s a very different statement than “every penny you make is taxed”.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  1
                  edit-2
                  5 months ago

                  A tax at 0% is still a tax, I feel people are purposively missing the point rather than debate them

                  • @Cryophilia
                    link
                    15 months ago

                    It’s literally exempt from taxation, that’s why they call it an exemption.

    • @solstice
      link
      2
      edit-2
      5 months ago

      It’s somewhat accurate to say “every penny they make is taxABLE to Uncle Sam” which is different from saying 100% tax rate. Americans living outside the US still need to file a tax return and report all their income, and pay tax on it to the US, even if it is from a foreign source. That said they could claim the foreign tax credit if they paid tax to a foreign regime on that income already, or the foreign income exclusion under some circumstances which would reduce their taxable income to the US.

      • @btaf45
        link
        35 months ago

        It’s somewhat accurate to say “every penny they make is taxABLE to Uncle Sam”

        It’s completely meaningless but hyperbolic to say that because that’s the way taxes work in every country. No country randomly ignores random amounts of income from taxation. Also, there is the concept of tax exempt income and the fact that pennies and dollar fractions are completely ignored on tax forms.

        • @solstice
          link
          15 months ago

          Calm down professor. The US is one of the only countries in the world to tax worldwide income, even if they are a nonresident of the US. That is NOT how it works in every country.

          Here’s a pretty good article about it from the WSJ if you want to educate yourself on the subject: https://www.wsj.com/articles/BL-WB-34630

          • @btaf45
            link
            15 months ago

            The US is one of the only countries in the world to tax worldwide income, even if they are a nonresident of the US.

            We all know that and this is not what is being discussed genius.

            That is NOT how it works in every country.

            Taking into considering “every penny” of your income IS how it works in every country.

            • @solstice
              link
              14 months ago

              You’re a very unpleasant person.

              • @btaf45
                link
                14 months ago

                You’re a huge dumbasshole.