MeldrikM to [email protected] • 1 month agoThat's great. That's great.lemmy.wtfimagemessage-square126fedilinkarrow-up1980arrow-down125
arrow-up1955arrow-down1imageThat's great. That's great.lemmy.wtfMeldrikM to [email protected] • 1 month agomessage-square126fedilink
minus-square@xantoxislink250•edit-21 month ago“I shot a guy in the head, but then a different guy moved into the house where he lived, so it wasn’t that bad?”
minus-square@[email protected]linkfedilinkEnglish10•1 month agoExcept there wasn’t even a house left. There was a smoking patch of ground that a different guy moved to.
minus-square@[email protected]linkfedilink7•1 month agoThis is the classic argument against act utilitarianism. It’s textbook ethics. Literally, every intro ethics textbook covers it.
“I shot a guy in the head, but then a different guy moved into the house where he lived, so it wasn’t that bad?”
That’s great. That’s great.
Yeah so it’s not as scary as people think
“I shot 1/4 million people in the head…”
But none of them were deputies!
Except there wasn’t even a house left. There was a smoking patch of ground that a different guy moved to.
This is the classic argument against act utilitarianism. It’s textbook ethics. Literally, every intro ethics textbook covers it.