Which platform would a typical IT guy be more on guard against?

While Windows has been known for decades to be a hot pot for all PC malware, Android phones are much more ubiquitous and personalized, and (as far as I know) aren’t hardened against malware in any way. I mean, it literally takes just two taps to install a rogue apk and that is notwithstanding that most OEM implementations and apps on the Play Store are ad-ridden privacy nightmares by themselves. At least when it comes to Windows, Administrators have greater control over client machines and can put in restrictions. How would someone handling infosec in an organization control security on people’s personal phones?

  • magic_lobster_party
    link
    fedilink
    131 year ago

    Hard to tell, but I would say Windows. It’s easier to fool users to download and run arbitrary executable files like ILOVEYOU.txt.exe on a PC. On Android you need to go through many more hoops and turns to run some unverified executable.

    Although Windows is pretty well guarded these days.

    • /home/pineapplelover
      link
      fedilink
      41 year ago

      Windows has a bunch of warnings if you try to download a virus. It even deletes it so you can’t run it. On stock android, I’ve experienced that it will give you red flags if you try to download any .apk. There are also downright malicious apps in the official Play Store too so downloading the recommended way isn’t safe either. Can’t say too much about Window’s store but idk anybody who actually uses that but I bet there are a couple malicious apps in there also. However, I think Windows has more protections in place out of both of the platforms.

      • magic_lobster_party
        link
        fedilink
        71 year ago

        I don’t think the average user knows how to run apk files on Android. On Windows running an exe is just like opening any other file.

        Malicious apps on Play store can be removed by Google. No one uses Windows App store to download programs.

        But I agree that once a user manages to run a malicious apk file they’re probably more vulnerable than the Windows user.

    • Dirk Darkly
      link
      fedilink
      31 year ago

      Although Windows is pretty well guarded these days.

      Besides all the unpatched vulnerabilities and zero-day exploits, of course.

      • slazer2au
        link
        31 year ago

        And android doesn’t? Have you seen any pwn20wn contests? Every vendor has bugs I would argue that due to the fractured android market they have more known problems that phone vendors aren’t patching.

        Ms at least has a known patch cycle of the second Tuesday of each month.