• @HowManyNimons
    link
    252 months ago
    1. Who the fuck is this Biden?
    2. Who decided where the zero point on these graphs’ axes are? The definition of a centrist is subjective and time-dependent.
    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      322 months ago

      There’s a reason why political compass is a meme. It’s a terrible way of organizing political ideology.

      • @Reddfugee42
        link
        English
        -62 months ago

        That’s melodramatic. It’s incomplete, that’s all. It is one legitimate component of an array of visualizations.

        • @pyre
          link
          8
          edit-2
          2 months ago

          it’s not incomplete, it’s dumb. the idea of “fiscally conservative, socially liberal” is a complete fantasy. right wing is authoritarian by nature, and left wing is “libertarian” by nature.

          (I’m using lowercase l “libertarian” in a very generic sense, not in the american libertarian “let’s get rid of the age of consent” sense.)

          • @HowManyNimons
            link
            22 months ago

            I think Kier Starmer is fiscally conservative and socially liberal.

            • @pyre
              link
              5
              edit-2
              2 months ago

              yeah but that just doesn’t work. fiscally conservative policies inevitably result in inequalities and preserve a hierarchical structure that keeps conservative norms intact.

              tbf liberalism is still a right wing position so i shouldn’t say the term is entirely inaccurate, but it’s generally used in the aforementioned lowercase-l libertarian sense, as if someone can be fiscally “right wing” (preserving inequality) and socially “left wing” (promoting equality). that simply cannot be achieved. you cannot achieve equality by preserving inequality. you’re still authoritarian.

              • @HowManyNimons
                link
                1
                edit-2
                2 months ago

                I want commenting on its efficacy. I’m just saying that it happens. Most economic conservatives these days come with a side order of rights oppression: reproductive, gender expression, migrants, etc. Starmer, while being fiscally conservative in that he isn’t going to introduce a programme of economic redistribution, is socially liberal in that he’s pushing back the former government’s “culture war” actions.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      72 months ago

      For 2., I think it’s useful to put the origin at the status quo/current conditions.

      For me, this helps to clarify my voting choices: if the candidate pushes you in the correct direction — even if only a little — then that’s a good thing!