• Graydon
    link
    fedilink
    132 months ago

    @bitofhope @swlabr One of those quiet little scientific revolutions; cheap genetic testing let biologists realise that insects they had classified as different species were not, they were different morphs using the same genes. This let in the idea of developmental plasticity and the current consensus is that a whole lot of stuff is developmental, not genetic.

    In humans, almost everything brain-based (sexuality, identity, language, symbol manipulation…) is likely significantly developmental.

    • Graydon
      link
      fedilink
      132 months ago

      @bitofhope @swlabr This completely messes with the idea that you can use “good genes” as a guarantee of a desirable outcome.

      It also hauls in the idea of environment as the arbiter in more-difficult-to-ignore ways. Even if you’re using Origin and nothing since, you should be aware that “fitness” means “in some specific environment and moment in time”, only there’s this drive to ditch that. Recognising how much developmental plasticity matters breaks any concept of inherent quality of organisms.