The Picard Maneuver to Lord of the [email protected]English • 3 months agoElves would neverimagemessage-square42arrow-up1828arrow-down15
arrow-up1823arrow-down1imageElves would neverThe Picard Maneuver to Lord of the [email protected]English • 3 months agomessage-square42
minus-square@TheGrandNaguslinkEnglish17•3 months agoYes, elves in the books are a lot more… human. They feast, they sing, they dance, they do stupid things, they prank each other. If anything they seem the most playful race. Shit, in The Hobbit, a soldier on duty gets so drunk that he passes out, allowing Bilbo and the Dwarves are able to escape in barrels. PJ very much took the Elves and said “let’s make them into Star Trek Vulcans!”
minus-square@CitizenKonglinkEnglish8•edit-23 months agoI’d say Tolkien is a bit inconsistent in how he portrays elves. In The Hobbit, they are more like frolicking, dancing and singing pixies and in LotR they are more ethereal and aloof like fey. Jackson chose to stick to the fey aspect.
minus-square@TattoracklinkEnglish6•3 months agoAren’t the elves from The Hobbit also a different group? It could just be that they are frolicking weirdos compared to Elrond’s and Galadriel’s elves.
minus-square@CitizenKonglinkEnglish3•3 months agoIt’s literally Elrond in The Hobbit as far as I recall.
minus-squarethreelonmusketeerslinkfedilinkEnglish2•3 months agoI think they’re referring to the Wood Elves they encounter on their way through Mirkwood.
minus-square@TattoracklinkEnglish1•3 months agoWell, Elrond was there in the beginning. Bilbo and the dwarves passed through Rivendel.
minus-square@[email protected]linkfedilinkEnglish2•edit-23 months agoThe playful, drunk elves of the Hobbit were wood elves; the stuffy ones were high elves I think PJ made them a bit too up themselves (Too stuck up, too snooty, too like the ideal British noble)
Yes, elves in the books are a lot more… human.
They feast, they sing, they dance, they do stupid things, they prank each other. If anything they seem the most playful race.
Shit, in The Hobbit, a soldier on duty gets so drunk that he passes out, allowing Bilbo and the Dwarves are able to escape in barrels.
PJ very much took the Elves and said “let’s make them into Star Trek Vulcans!”
I’d say Tolkien is a bit inconsistent in how he portrays elves. In The Hobbit, they are more like frolicking, dancing and singing pixies and in LotR they are more ethereal and aloof like fey.
Jackson chose to stick to the fey aspect.
Aren’t the elves from The Hobbit also a different group? It could just be that they are frolicking weirdos compared to Elrond’s and Galadriel’s elves.
It’s literally Elrond in The Hobbit as far as I recall.
I think they’re referring to the Wood Elves they encounter on their way through Mirkwood.
Well, Elrond was there in the beginning. Bilbo and the dwarves passed through Rivendel.
The playful, drunk elves of the Hobbit were wood elves; the stuffy ones were high elves
I think PJ made them a bit too up themselves
(Too stuck up, too snooty, too like the ideal British noble)