• @MataVatnik
    link
    English
    43 days ago

    Roman forces had a system for rotating troops in and out of the very front line of combat in the middle of a battle (like hockey players mid game), so yes it would only make sense to have the shields there for those who are actively fighting.

    Also I can’t imagine this was a regular occurrence

    • @PugJesusOPM
      link
      English
      93 days ago

      Also I can’t imagine this was a regular occurrence

      So far as I know, this is the only occurrence of it happening.

      The Iazyges were conquered by the Romans on land at this time and later on the river. By this I do not mean that any naval battle took place, but that the Romans pursued them as they fled over the frozen Ister [Danube] and fought there as on dry land. The Iazyges, perceiving that they were being pursued, awaited their opponents’ onset, expecting to overcome them easily, as the others were not accustomed to the ice. Accordingly, some of the barbarians dashed straight at them, while others rode round to attack their flanks, as their horses had been trained to run safely even over a surface of this kind. The Romans upon observing this were not alarmed, but formed in a compact body, fa­cing all their foes at once, and most of them laid down their shields and rested one foot upon them, so that they might not slip so much; and thus they received the enemy’s charge. Some seized the bridles, others the shields and spearshafts of their assailants, and drew the men toward them; and thus, becoming involved in close conflict, they knocked down both men and horses, since the barbarians by reason of their momentum could no longer keep from slipping. The Romans, to be sure, also slipped; but in case one of them fell on his back, he would drag his adversary down on top of him and then with his feet would hurl him backwards, as in a wrestling match, and so would get on top of him

      -Cassius Dio, 72.7

      • @MataVatnik
        link
        English
        23 days ago

        and most of them laid down their shields and rested one foot upon them

        Looks like it actually was a lot of them that did it.

        • @PugJesusOPM
          link
          English
          23 days ago

          The Romans upon observing this were not alarmed, but formed in a compact body, fa­cing all their foes at once,

          may be suggesting that they formed a square, as Roman legions sometimes did, which would leave a number of troops on the ‘inside’ of the formation without an immediate need for a shield.