- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
Most who seek surrogacy overseas, which is now punishable by jail terms and fines, are heterosexual couples
Most who seek surrogacy overseas, which is now punishable by jail terms and fines, are heterosexual couples
What do you think about “altruistic surrogacy”, mentioned in the article? Presumably if someone is volunteering that avoids the exploitation angle?
Approaching from another angle, do you think sex work should be legal? It’s another area where exploitation and abuse are a concern. But if we expect someone can earn money using their body in one area (sex work, or even just physical labor) then why should it be illegal to earn money by carrying a baby to term? Exploitation should be made illegal, not the act itself.
Lastly, my understanding is that surrogacy is more often used when a woman is unable to carry the baby, than when a man is unable to impregnate.
I hear you that rich people are selfish and causing any number of problems. That said, I think your approach misses the suffering of many normal people who want to raise a child and would be unable to otherwise.
Even if this was an activity that someone thinks should be restricted, should it be punishable with jail time? I don’t think so. The law in Italy seems clearly designed to target LGBT people.
Volunteering is fine!
People use their bodies for work, true. The difference when it comes to surrogacy is that
Regarding sex work, you’re right; it’s so profitable and ubiquitous that by making it illegal we just create a black market (like drugs). Since this black market is one of the main sources of harm for that industry, by legalizing and regulating it we also make sex work less exploitative and dangerous. In contrast, surrogacy is neither ubiquitous nor profitable (hence the exploitation of poor foreign girls).