• Nougat
    link
    fedilink
    702 months ago

    You’re right, it is. But language shifts in populations in ways that enhance communication. One person using letters that nobody else uses makes communication of ideas more difficult.

    Not only that, but they’re only choosing to use some Middle English letters, and not any other rules of Middle English grammar or spelling.

    They can use whatever language they want, but if it’s too much effort for people to understand, they’re more likely to be ignored.

    • @ComicalMayhem
      link
      32 months ago

      can we just go back to Homestuck-esque typing quirks?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      -92 months ago

      You’re right, it is. But language shifts in populations in ways that enhance communication. One person using letters pronouns that nobody else uses makes communication of ideas more difficult.

      Not only that, but they’re only choosing to use some Middle English letters english pronouns, and not any other rules of Middle English grammar or spelling different types of english pronouns.

      They can use whatever language pronouns they want, but if it’s too much effort for people to understand, they’re more likely to be ignored.

      Doesn’t sound so reasonable now, does it? If language that mildly inconveniences others is an acceptable way to express your gender identity, then why not also to express yourself creatively?

      • Nougat
        link
        fedilink
        102 months ago

        One, pronous are not letters, and letters are not pronouns. I’m not offending anyone’s gender by suggesting that using “þ” instead of “th” when trying to communicate in English on the internet in 2024 is counterproductive.

        Two, gendered pronouns are some of the very oldest words in English, and they are used very regularly. They are engrained in native English speakers from birth. Each of us has a very long history of thinking in terms of these gendered pronouns, and I will grant that those who are younger have an easier time of making gender shifts with pronouns than those who are older.

        There’s a reason people aren’t using xe/xey, for example. Somebody just made it up and said “use it.” Language doesn’t work by fiat (unless we’re talking about a colonizer eliminating indigenous languages by literal force). In terms of gender neutral pronouns, we already have the singular “they,” which has been in use to some degree since at least Early Modern English.

        I can wholly respect and support someone’s gender and refuse to use nonsense words at the same time. Think about where gendered pronouns are used: when one person talks to a second person about a third person. If that third person is genderfluid in some way, I’m going to use “they” when referring to them (see what I did there?), because the second person is most likely to understand what I’m saying.

        And before you get all fucking uppity again, I’ve had many lengthy conversations about this and so many other gender issues with my son, who is, among so many other things, trans.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          32 months ago

          I don’t even necessarily disagree that it’s counterproductive, I just don’t think it’s fair to attack someone for using esoteric or unconventional language. Yes, it inconveniences the listener - or in this case the reader - but in this context no one is being forced to engage with OP. By using some Old English letters OP is just having some innocent fun at no one’s expense, which doesn’t warrant the harsh response they’re receiving.

          If you were talking to someone and they casually used xe/xey pronouns (or any neopronouns for that matter) to refer to a friend who isn’t there, would you go out of your way to lecture them about what an inconvenience it is to you to have to learn something new?

          • Nougat
            link
            fedilink
            -12 months ago

            Please refer to point one of my previous comment.

    • Ð Greıt Þu̇mpkinOP
      link
      fedilink
      -492 months ago

      You aren’t owed prescriptive compliance just because you’re used to a worse system.

      Let alone if you feel like going out of ð way to justify shitting on oðer people’s innocent fun.