As science and methods advance, new data should be considered in the context of the full weight of available evidence, not as a complete replacement of the previous body of evidence—especially when considering an ingredient as safely and widely used as PE. CHPA will review the Proposed Order and submit comments accordingly," Melville said.

Yeah, it was. The old studies were reviewed and found to be lacking in foundation; new studies showed no better than placebo. Sorry about your golden parachute, Melville. Maybe don’t hawk snake oil if you don’t want to get treated like a snake oil salesman.