Summary

Jacob Hersant, a self-described Nazi, was sentenced to one month in prison, becoming the first person in Australia jailed for performing an outlawed Nazi salute.

Convicted in Victoria for making the salute outside a courthouse in October, Hersant’s act followed new legislation banning the gesture.

Magistrate Brett Sonnet justified the sentence, citing Hersant’s intent to promote Nazi ideology publicly.

Hersant’s lawyer argued that his actions were nonviolent and claimed they were protected as political expression, stating plans to appeal the ruling on constitutional grounds.

  • @Doomsider
    link
    English
    17
    edit-2
    4 days ago

    Man, that is some seriously fucked up shit to say. Not only did you miss the point, you pointed out you are a massive incel. Have fun defending Nazis.

    • @Mango
      link
      English
      -184 days ago

      I don’t care that he’s a Nazi. I care that what I consider to be his inviolable rights have been violated. His political shit should be as free to express as any other. Imagine it Trump goes and makes it illegal to indicate yourself as a Democrat. Wouldn’t be surprised if he did that after seeing your attitude, because I’m sure you’re more reasonable than him and doing it anyhow.

      • @Rice_Daddy
        link
        English
        114 days ago

        Tolerance of intolerance is not a path to freedom. Choosing to do nothing will only mean that rights and freedoms will be destroyed. Call this the lesser of two evils if you must.

        If you let intolerance fester, it will grow and take control, then it will start hurting and squeezing others. It’d be foolish to sacrifice freedom in the name of freedom.

        • @Mango
          link
          English
          -124 days ago

          So why do you think I should tolerate this? Why is your intolerance excused?

          • @Rice_Daddy
            link
            English
            64 days ago

            Are you worried about being jailed for Nazi views? So you should be, and consider yourself lucky. I’d rather have you jailed for a month to hopefully learn your lesson that we don’t take to hatred and violence lightly, than to allow you a platform to gather support so you can hurt and kill millions.

            • @Mango
              link
              English
              -53 days ago

              I don’t have Nazi views. I have American views of free speech. You’re the person trying to hurt people.

              • @Rice_Daddy
                link
                English
                63 days ago

                This law seems to be explicitly in place to avoid people getting hurt. You have not provided any argument at all how it doesn’t.

                • @Mango
                  link
                  English
                  -43 days ago

                  Nobody is hurt by a gesture. Sticks and stones. You want these people hiding themselves? I imagine it’s better they stay in the open. I’m sure someone is out there making a list.

                  We can’t use the same tactics that would be used to suppress minorities to go after them because we become them that way.

                  • @Rice_Daddy
                    link
                    English
                    53 days ago

                    Thank you for providing an actual argument.

                    As we have witnessed in many places, these stuff isn’t always outlawed. In places where these views can be expressed more freely, it either escalate to the point where someone is hurt, or they gain enough popularity that it becomes almost impossible to stop. I believe that the best way to deal with the problem is to address it quickly head on when we know this is universally abhorrent.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                English
                33 days ago

                I have not once heard of legislation here that genuinely violated people’s rights other than Victoria’s snap lockdown of a group of apartment buildings during COVID, which got the government into a class action lawsuit.

                Saying you value free speech, then saying that people who can violate others rights should also have freedom of speech in that regard, seems like you don’t know anything about what free speech is all about.

          • @Valmond
            link
            English
            3
            edit-2
            4 days ago

            Tolerate what exactly? Not following the law? Tolerate the law that is in favour of freedom and democracy?

            Edit: you font discuss in good faith so just forget it.

            • @Mango
              link
              English
              -33 days ago

              I do not tolerate a law that is NOT in favor of freedom.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                English
                43 days ago

                In Australia, and likely in most other countries, rights come with responsibilities. Our freedom of political communication, as outlined in the Victorian Human Rights Charter, doesn’t allow us to infringe on others’ rights to feel safe. Public expressions of neonazism can intimidate and threaten community safety, which limits that freedom. Just as we can’t harass or incite violence, any form of expression that undermines others’ rights to safety is restricted.

                I myself also believe freedoms shouldn’t be tarnished by outrageous legislation, but I don’t believe this is an example of that, as it protects other people’s rights more than the ones prosecuted.

              • @Valmond
                link
                English
                33 days ago

                You’re just a bad faith baiter lol

                • @Mango
                  link
                  English
                  -23 days ago

                  I’m not. You’re just the kind of person who parrots lines like that without any regards to it’s meaning.

      • @Doomsider
        link
        English
        104 days ago

        Yeah, I get it. You support hate speech and Nazis under the guise of free speech. I wouldn’t be surprised if date rape is the only way you will ever get laid.

        • @Mango
          link
          English
          -124 days ago

          Removed by mod

          • @Doomsider
            link
            English
            16
            edit-2
            3 days ago

            Not really. You thought bringing up raping a woman flippantly in a discussion was legitimate thus outing yourself as an incel.

            This is really simple. Hate speech is not protected speech. Arguing about free speech in the context of Nazism is just a dog whistle for racists. So now you are a racist incel. I think you see where this is going.

            On a personal level. Go find a new schtick. If you don’t want to be known as a Nazi, don’t defend Nazis. There is a world of people who need your righteous indignation.

      • @Valmond
        link
        English
        2
        edit-2
        3 days ago

        mY inViOlAbLe riGhTs to be a nazi!

        Do you even listen to yourself? Or are you just trying to stir up hate so that you can feel prosecuted?

        • @Mango
          link
          English
          -1
          edit-2
          3 days ago

          Yes, people have a right to identify how they like, think what they like, and communicate what they like so long as that communication isn’t a threat on another individual or cause a panic.

          I’m not a Nazi, but that guy is and you’re obviously persecuting him.

          • @Valmond
            link
            English
            13 days ago

            Is it should be.