• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    619 days ago

    All positions of power can (and will) be exploited. While religion has been used to justify a lot of bad things, so has a lot of other things. Religion is also a lot of good things, like culture, philosophy and wisdom passing through generations.

    It is also worth noting that you criticise religion as a whole, but all your links are about Christianity.

    I point this out, because I used to be a hardcore White atheist and I had a lot of bad takes. A lot of indigenous religions do not have the same ideas about hierarchy and even the Christian idea that humans are above nature often does not exist.

    Hierarchies are a bad thing in all* forms, but hierarchies are not necessary for religion.

    • Maestro
      link
      fedilink
      319 days ago

      They kinda are, though. My take is that all organised religion is bad. But what is the difference between a personal belief and a religion? It’s pretty much the level of organisation. And with organisation comes hierarchies.

      • NoneOfUrBusiness
        link
        fedilink
        519 days ago

        Uh… No? A religion is a belief system shared by many people. Organization, let alone hierarchies is optional but not at all necessary. For example as a Muslim I’d argue that at least mainstream Sunni Islam (excluding deviant groups such as Sufists) doesn’t fit the Western concept of organized religion. Setting aside the merits and demerits of religion, it feels to me that discussion on this topic on English-speaking media is very eurocentric for the conclusions it attempts to reach.

        • @yetiftw
          link
          English
          319 days ago

          to be honest Judaism isn’t particularly organized either. there is no central authority past each synagogue’s own rabbi and even then their “authority” is rather limited