#Km91# to [email protected]English • 1 month agoE...dward..sh.itjust.worksimagemessage-square9fedilinkarrow-up1145arrow-down115
arrow-up1130arrow-down1imageE...dward..sh.itjust.works#Km91# to [email protected]English • 1 month agomessage-square9fedilink
minus-square🇰 🌀 🇱 🇦 🇳 🇦 🇰 ℹ️linkfedilinkEnglish3•1 month agoSo uh… Which is worse: The fact Nina was turned into her own dog or the fact that Scar killed her for being turned into a dog? 🤔
minus-squareCosmonaut_Collinlink22•1 month agoI think Scars actions can be justified as a mercy killing. The father can not be justified in his actions.
minus-square#Km91#OPlinkfedilinkEnglish11•edit-21 month agoConsidering that the one turning her was her father, the first one. Also her brain was half way gone at that point.
minus-square@[email protected]linkfedilink5•1 month agoDefinitely the first one. Not even comparable. To me, her dad could have many skeletons in the closet with the justification that he is doing it so his daughter can thrive. I cannot begin to imagine what he believed he was saving with that sacrifice. Why did he do it?
minus-square@ZorquelinkEnglish3•edit-21 month agoEgo. Desperation. He did it to his wife years before, which started his rise to alchemy stardom… he just needed some way to keep it going. The real discussion is why he never went out and got transients (or refugees) to experiment on. Too much work? More likely to fight back? Hard to say.
So uh… Which is worse:
The fact Nina was turned into her own dog or the fact that Scar killed her for being turned into a dog? 🤔
I think Scars actions can be justified as a mercy killing. The father can not be justified in his actions.
Considering that the one turning her was her father, the first one. Also her brain was half way gone at that point.
Definitely the first one. Not even comparable.
To me, her dad could have many skeletons in the closet with the justification that he is doing it so his daughter can thrive.
I cannot begin to imagine what he believed he was saving with that sacrifice. Why did he do it?
Ego. Desperation. He did it to his wife years before, which started his rise to alchemy stardom… he just needed some way to keep it going.
The real discussion is why he never went out and got transients (or refugees) to experiment on. Too much work? More likely to fight back? Hard to say.