Summary

School districts across the U.S. are reducing bus services due to driver shortages and shifting transportation responsibilities to families, disproportionately affecting low-income households.

In Chicago, where only 17,000 of 325,000 students are eligible for buses, parents are turning to alternatives like ride-hailing apps.

Startups such as Piggyback Network and HopSkipDrive provide school transportation by connecting parents or contracting directly with districts, offering safety measures like real-time tracking and driver vetting.

Critics warn these solutions don’t fully address systemic inequities, as many families still struggle to afford or access reliable school transportation.

  • Flying Squid
    link
    61 day ago

    How many traffic light-free four-lane highways did you have to cross? More or less than zero? How often did cars zip by you in the darkness going 150% the speed limit?

    Because you ignored those things that I brought up and talked about distance, which I didn’t mention.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      -61 day ago

      First you’re talking about living in a rural area, then you’re talking about 4 lane highways. Which one is it?

      • Flying Squid
        link
        6
        edit-2
        1 day ago

        Both? Because that’s how it works in America?

        Are you really unaware that four-lane highways criss-cross their way through the American countryside?

        Here’s the state of Indiana, where I live, and all of the major highways and interstates. Obviously a lot of tiny towns with population 50 are left off, but I think you can figure out that “both” is how things work here:

        And if that doesn’t help you, this is Indiana compared to Ireland:

        Indiana, incidentally, is nowhere near the largest U.S. state.

        Perhaps you should know how things work in a country before you start coming up with what you think are obvious solutions.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          -324 hours ago

          Are you really unaware that four-lane highways criss-cross their way through the American countryside?

          Sure, we also have highways that cross the countryside as well as E-roads (european international roads, which would be comparable to interstates). Not sure why that would be dangerous though, highways don’t have level crossings, ever. Doesn’t really matter if you go by car or bike, a level crossing on a highway would be suicidal.

          • Flying Squid
            link
            323 hours ago

            I don’t know what a “level crossing” is, but you still have not justified a school child crossing a four-lane highway with no traffic lights in the dark on foot or a bicycle every day to get to school. I’m just astounded that you can’t seem to understand that’s a way to get children killed.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              -3
              edit-2
              17 hours ago

              I don’t know what a “level crossing” is

              A place where roads cross at the same level, so a normal intersection. As apposed to a non-level crossing like a tunnel or bridge, where roads cross at different levels. Traffic on highways moves too fast and is too dense for level crossings so crossing a highway is one of the safest crossings you can ever make because you never have to actually cross traffic.

              Highways don’t have intersections, it’s one of the defining features of a highway.

              • Flying Squid
                link
                6
                edit-2
                17 hours ago

                Highways don’t have intersections, it’s one of the defining features of a highway.

                Once again, maybe learn a little about the place where you’re talking about before you think there are “obvious” solutions. There’s literally an intersection with no traffic lights where the rural road crosses the highway.

                This isn’t the intersection I am talking about, but it’s a typical one:

                And no, one road is not going underneath the other there. It is what you call a level crossing. No lights, no sidewalks, no stop signs, no reason for the cars to ever slow down or stop.

                And no street lights.

                You keep avoiding the fact that this would easily get a child killed and I’m starting to think it’s because you just don’t care if a child is killed as long as they are walking or biking.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  016 hours ago

                  There’s literally an intersection with no traffic lights where the rural road crosses the highway.

                  That’s not a highway as I understand the term. When I read ‘highway’ I expect something like this. By definition they are conflict-free (no crossings, traffic lights, access only through on/off ramps that allow you to match speed, etc.

                  Do you not have safety/design standards for roads where you are? Because that definitely looks like a road that would be required to have traffic lights. What is the max allowed speed on that road?

                  It looks like what would be a 80 or 100 km/h road here. 80 km/h roads are fine to cross safely if they are single-lane, dual-lane (2+2) or 100km/h roads always have traffic lights. Highways are 130km/h and never have intersections.

                  And no street lights.

                  That’s just insane. A road like that would be required to have street lights here. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a road that size without lights. The only roads without street lights here are narrow, low-speed rural roads (the kind where you have to slow down and drive partially on the shoulder when you meet an oncoming car) and they usually still have a light at intersections.

                  • Flying Squid
                    link
                    515 hours ago

                    What? You mean things in the U.S. aren’t like they are where you live and so what “normal” kids like you do where you live isn’t in any way safe for them to do here? Which is what I’ve been saying this entire fucking time?

                  • @[email protected]
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    4
                    edit-2
                    15 hours ago

                    Yeah, I’m from Kentucky (a state touching Indiana). My understanding is that, in Kentucky, a highway is a numbered road maintained by the state. Local roads get names and are maintained by the city or county.

                    Highways where I grew up were straight and had a 55mph speed limit. Side/local roads would intersect the highway. The side road would have a stop sign but the highway would not. Street lights were rare, and only in areas that were a bit more built up.

                    Edit: and the biking school commute Google suggested for me takes me down 2 highways.