If you sit down next to a cat, and throw your arm over the back of the sofa while someone reaches over from behind and starts to pet the cat, and then after a little bit you stand up and leave while the phantom arm is still petting the cat, the cat understands that something really freaky is happening, gets scared, and runs away.

I would have thought they’d be happy that whatever weird thing is happening is petting them, but apparently not. An arm with no human is alarming and bad. I think it’s cool that their mental model is that similar to ours.

  • Lvxferre
    link
    fedilink
    English
    145 days ago

    Mammals in general are so smart that I wonder if this mental model is shared by the whole class, or at least the Boreoeutheria (clade that includes both carnivores and primates, plus a lot more critters). And, like, the evolutionary benefits of that model are obvious - if whatever tore your arm apart is still lying around, you need to run away ASAP.

    • AwkwardLookMonkeyPuppet
      link
      English
      105 days ago

      Birds are very smart too, some of them are much smarter than the average mammal.

      • @KnightontheSun
        link
        English
        95 days ago

        I remember an article not long ago about a songbird that “riffs” within its song. Something like a jazz musician might. I’m fuzzy on the details, but this was stated as a sign of intelligence. The theory is that neural density might be variable based on the species…or something. Basically even that a bird brain can be intelligent and capable of some level of free thinking. We all know about crows and their street smarts too.

      • Lvxferre
        link
        fedilink
        English
        24 days ago

        Some of them are really smart indeed, and I wouldn’t be surprised if they developed a similar mental model through convergent evolution.