• @Doorbook
    link
    131 month ago

    It is worth the try. That is a generational wealth.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      231 month ago

      It’s also a futile attempt. In the off chance they even find it, that hard drive would be toast by then. In a landfill, that hard drive would prob be shattered and in pieces, not to mention probably corroded and unreadable.

      • @Coreidan
        link
        English
        41 month ago

        Shattered? Very unlikely. Corroded? Maybe, but probably not since hard drives are well sealed.

        They would just need a section of the platter to be readable, they area with the sector that has the data they need. Even if the platter was shattered it would be possible to read the block you need.

        The chances are low but the reward is worth the effort.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          81 month ago

          Hard drives, except for helium-filled ones, actually have an air hole in them with a filter attached to it so they can keep enough air in the drive so the heads can properly fly over the disk surface. Completely possible that moisture ingress would be an issue after years of sitting in a landfill in who knows what. It is a darn tiny hole though.

          • @Coreidan
            link
            English
            51 month ago

            Yea but only one way to find out. Making massive assumptions when 700 mill is on the line seems dumb. Never give up.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              11 month ago

              Oh yeah, I’d still try too. Once rescued a phone from a saltwater beach. It sat there buried for 6 months ish in saltwater. Was able to extract all the data from the MicroSD card and find the owner to give them their lost pictures and such. Would still try, despite knowing the science.

              Unrelated, f cell manufacturers for removing MicroSD card slots.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          51 month ago

          I’d wager all the machine compacting and shredding they do at a landfill would render any harddrive broken. Maybe it survived, but after all these years, I highly doubt it survived being expoded to the elements anyways

        • @IphtashuFitz
          link
          English
          31 month ago

          Have you ever seen a modern landfill? For one thing they crush the contents by constantly rolling over it with a steamroller with spiked wheels that’s designed to shred & compact the trash as much as possible. Then there’s corrosive materials in the garbage that mixes with rainwater to create a leechate that will corrode other garbage as it seeps through it.

          I’d be shocked if a standard hard drive could survive a decade in such an environment.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        01 month ago

        It’s quite amazing how much data can be recovered from hard drives that have been even in fires. I think they recovered like 95% of the data from the hard drives on the challenger shuttle that blew up.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      31 month ago

      I feel like this is an argument of Expected Value.

      Ex. if the harddrive has $X on it, and there’s a Y% chance of finding it over the course of a lifetime, then the expected value of the search is X*Y). But if Y is so low that it would take 10 lifetimes to have a better than 50% chance (we’ll say a 6.5% chance if you searched your whole life), it doesn’t matter if X is $742 million (so that the Expected Value is about $50 million) or $742 billion, it’s still objectively a waste of a life.