Forcing a people to be part of your system against their wishes is subjugation. The Ukrainians wanted independence. They literally fought for it and lost. Excusing genocide because there was some bonus education is disgusting. Excusing imperialism because you like the perks makes you an imperialist.
Forcing a people to be part of your system against their wishes
Source: Ukrainian nationalist propaganda.
The Ukrainians wanted independence. They literally fought for it and lost
A part of the population in a small region of Ukraine wanted anarchism, and was promptly defeated by communists in the context of a civil war against fascism because anarchy doesn’t work. Ukrainians should thank the soviets for the ensuing industrialisation that allowed the defeat of the Nazis, a sparse set of agricultural communes would have been exterminated by Nazis. Anarchists simply don’t understand this, and refuse to understand the historical and material conditions that surround them in favour of idealism, which is why their projects don’t live long enough to see widespread adoption anywhere.
Excusing genocide
The lack of prior attempts, the lack or motives, the lack of intent, the fact that it was a famine in a particular event of land collectivisation, and the fact that there was no continuation over time, prove it wasn’t a genocide. I’m not excusing genocide because there wasn’t, I’m criticising poor collectivisation policy which led to famine both inside and outside Ukraine.
Excusing imperialism
Consolidating socialism in a region isn’t imperialism, which you’d know, again, if you had read any socialist literature. But you’d rather go with your vibes-based Reddit leftism.
OK genocide apologist.
Forcing a people to be part of your system against their wishes is subjugation. The Ukrainians wanted independence. They literally fought for it and lost. Excusing genocide because there was some bonus education is disgusting. Excusing imperialism because you like the perks makes you an imperialist.
Source: Ukrainian nationalist propaganda.
A part of the population in a small region of Ukraine wanted anarchism, and was promptly defeated by communists in the context of a civil war against fascism because anarchy doesn’t work. Ukrainians should thank the soviets for the ensuing industrialisation that allowed the defeat of the Nazis, a sparse set of agricultural communes would have been exterminated by Nazis. Anarchists simply don’t understand this, and refuse to understand the historical and material conditions that surround them in favour of idealism, which is why their projects don’t live long enough to see widespread adoption anywhere.
The lack of prior attempts, the lack or motives, the lack of intent, the fact that it was a famine in a particular event of land collectivisation, and the fact that there was no continuation over time, prove it wasn’t a genocide. I’m not excusing genocide because there wasn’t, I’m criticising poor collectivisation policy which led to famine both inside and outside Ukraine.
Consolidating socialism in a region isn’t imperialism, which you’d know, again, if you had read any socialist literature. But you’d rather go with your vibes-based Reddit leftism.