No, it does not magic more manpower out of thin air. As you said, though, it is a war of attrition. It cuts down the attrition. That matters, because right now Russia remains unable to sweep through Ukraine and is having to offer more and more to offset its own attrition. Tank depots are running dry. Inflation is spiking. Ukraine gets away with its economy being fucked becase Europe is propping it up with funding.
Giving up territory now without meaningful security guarantees does nothing to prevent Russia from coming back for more later. Like how it took Crimea in 2014 and came back for more. Like what it did in Chechnya. Like what it did in Georgia. Russia got away with it once, it did it again. Giving up a portion of Ukrainian territory without actual backup isn’t just that, it’s surrendering entirely to being a Russian puppet state, because if Ukraine does anything against Russia’s interests then Russia just comes back for more.
Tell me, how much of your own country would you give up to an invader that acts like that? What if it was the part you lived in?
If it was so obvious then Russia obviously knows too and it should just be explicit. Ukraine can’t rely on implications here. The Budapest memorandum clearly wasn’t good enough.
Territory can be regained
By what means? More bloodshed? Or are you hoping the invader just decides to return it out of the goodness of their own heart?
Considering the long history of Russification in Russia’s territories, life doesn’t just get to go on and family and friends are not all alive and well.
deleted by creator
No, it does not magic more manpower out of thin air. As you said, though, it is a war of attrition. It cuts down the attrition. That matters, because right now Russia remains unable to sweep through Ukraine and is having to offer more and more to offset its own attrition. Tank depots are running dry. Inflation is spiking. Ukraine gets away with its economy being fucked becase Europe is propping it up with funding.
Giving up territory now without meaningful security guarantees does nothing to prevent Russia from coming back for more later. Like how it took Crimea in 2014 and came back for more. Like what it did in Chechnya. Like what it did in Georgia. Russia got away with it once, it did it again. Giving up a portion of Ukrainian territory without actual backup isn’t just that, it’s surrendering entirely to being a Russian puppet state, because if Ukraine does anything against Russia’s interests then Russia just comes back for more.
Tell me, how much of your own country would you give up to an invader that acts like that? What if it was the part you lived in?
deleted by creator
If it was so obvious then Russia obviously knows too and it should just be explicit. Ukraine can’t rely on implications here. The Budapest memorandum clearly wasn’t good enough.
By what means? More bloodshed? Or are you hoping the invader just decides to return it out of the goodness of their own heart?
Considering the long history of Russification in Russia’s territories, life doesn’t just get to go on and family and friends are not all alive and well.
deleted by creator
Sounds like it matters who’s in charge then, doesn’t it?
deleted by creator
How do you not realise how contradictory what you’re saying is?
deleted by creator