TLDR: upvote if you want BuyFromEU to stick around.
Hi folks, new mod here.
There are two quite similar communities on different instances. Some users - coming from the different place - are in favor for abandoning this one, fearing a split and unecessary separation of users for an important movement. I’m not so sure if the other one is a substitute. Also - to be honest - I dislike the agressive, relentless style some users use in a -if you will- foreign community.
Procedure
- An upvote on this post means this you want this community to evolve. I would then proceed and search for more moderators and try to keep this a productive, interconnected space.
- A downvote means you are in favor of abandoning and settling with the other community.
You can use the comments on this post to express your feelings in a civil manner.
I’ll finally check back in about 48hours and take a look at where we are standing.
Edit:
Related posts for those who like digging in the past
Well if you ask me alone, I would say I wouldn’t like to. I have an answer to the question “why” here: https://sopuli.xyz/comment/14953580
But that isn’t up to me - rather would have to ask Sunshine and the community there.
Well, seems like we are going to have a similar poll on the other side x)
Lemmy needs a poll-post implementation, like mastodon!
Hey, relax. You don’t need to disband your community either. It is not winner takes it all. It is just about these 1000 people in this community wantig to keep it alive or not.
Your community is unique as it is related to your website. Also crossposting should benefit both of the communities well enough. There is no need to vanish and/or merge at any cost.
Not sure what you mean by this, is the website https://buy-european.net/ ? But the community was created without any link to the website, @[email protected] joined Lemmy yesterday.
Crossposting splinters discussion even further.
Those three discussion threads are happening in parallel, people replying in one won’t see the comments in the other except if they explicitly visit the crossposts.
Yea, [email protected] is perfect for redirections coming from http://buy-european.net People might engage dev there asking stuff about the page, or suggesting new features.
Maybe it is okay to have splintert discussions, as communities could have different viewpoints. This can be enriching.
Which different viewpoints would people on [email protected] and [email protected] have?
I still have to find anyone no wanting to use https://www.infomaniak.com/ because they are Swiss.
Splintering the conversation means that an interesting information in a comment will only be seen be the people reading that community’s crosspost and not the people reading the crosspost in the community.
And if we expect people to post all of their comments and posts twice so that both communities have all the content, why not consider merging them?
Exactly. That’s how crossposting works. Nothing bad there. Otherwise we can just close all servers and start over with only one instance for everyone and call it reddit.
Where are the alternatives communities of
They all died because one community became “the one”
The reason parallel communities still exist is usually because there is an ideological issue between the two.
What is the reason behind the existence of those two communities except the fact that the creator of [email protected] wasn’t aware that [email protected] existed?
Feddit.org and feddit.uk have similar moderation policies and rules.
https://feddit.org/post/8682570 links to https://buy-european.net/category/email-providers , which includes Protonmail, a Swiss provider. Are you going to remove that post from [email protected] as it does not strictly list EU alternatives?
Ah sorry don’t misunderstand me: I am fine with two communities co-existing and I also was eager to add buyfromeu to our sidebar if people want specifically EU centric community.
The biggest problem I personally had was that I couldn’t reach the mod of this community to discuss. But you have now taken over the moderation so that’s good!
I do generally agree with Blaze that lemmy has a bit of an issue with splintered communities while it is small still, but I’m also fine with this community staying and appreciate you volunteering to mod it and keep it active.