• @teamevil
    link
    2211 months ago

    Where as I don’t disagree with the timing being retaliatory, my parents have similar trees and my father had me do that just before he passed away. I was convinced I was killing the trees and turns out their canopy is larger than ever now, so it might not be terrible for trees, but still timing is bullshit.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      3911 months ago

      I’m not an arborist and we don’t have those type of tree where I live, but I have worked in landscaping before. My understanding any substantial trimming like that I’ve done in the past should never be done in the hottest part of the year because the tree will have trouble retaining water.

      • Regular Human
        link
        2311 months ago

        That’s the main thing. Pollard your trees when they’re in winter dormancy, not mid summer while they’re actually using leaves to respirate

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          1111 months ago

          This looks more like tipping than pollarding to me. If it’s supposed to be pollarding whoever’s doing it is shit at it. Tipping is harmful to trees, and based on the photos of the tree prior to it being cut it looks like it may have been tipped once in the year already (likely why they weren’t issued a permit by the city and cut it illegally).

          • Regular Human
            link
            411 months ago

            Oh yeah, these are obdurate plant butchers in action. This is inexcusable

    • @too_much_too_soon
      link
      4
      edit-2
      11 months ago

      bad for carbon sequestration,

      The trim is negligible when you are talking about carbon sequestration in the scheme of things too. I’m not sure how the other points stand up either - but the timing would suggest it is an insult to the labour.