VagabondShad to RPGMemes @ttrpg.networkEnglish • 2 years agoClassic puzzle, new approach or just a "two kinds of people" moment?ttrpg.networkimagemessage-square30fedilinkarrow-up1635arrow-down115
arrow-up1620arrow-down1imageClassic puzzle, new approach or just a "two kinds of people" moment?ttrpg.networkVagabondShad to RPGMemes @ttrpg.networkEnglish • 2 years agomessage-square30fedilink
minus-square@chaosTechnicianlink14•2 years agoThe full setup is that they can both tell you about the setup, but for the One Question, they follow the rules stipulated. Neither is actually bound to always lie and always tell the truth outside of the One Question.
minus-squaresome_guylinkfedilink-7•2 years agoWell yeah you can make anything work when the rules change on a whim
minus-squareCileTheSanelinkfedilink14•2 years agoWhen you are literally making the rules yes. It’s a riddle. There’s no “real world application” here.
minus-squareCileTheSanelinkfedilink5•2 years agoYes, the exact same thing said by the person you accused of changing the rules on a whim.
minus-squareCileTheSanelinkfedilink5•2 years agoThe “real” ones. I guess those are the rules “real” guards use in real life? It’s a riddle. The rules are whatever suits the riddle being presented.
The full setup is that they can both tell you about the setup, but for the One Question, they follow the rules stipulated. Neither is actually bound to always lie and always tell the truth outside of the One Question.
Well yeah you can make anything work when the rules change on a whim
When you are literally making the rules yes. It’s a riddle. There’s no “real world application” here.
deleted by creator
Yes, the exact same thing said by the person you accused of changing the rules on a whim.
deleted by creator
The “real” ones. I guess those are the rules “real” guards use in real life?
It’s a riddle. The rules are whatever suits the riddle being presented.