Very good analysis vid on what Team RWBY does wrong throughout the series. Their points are quite compelling.

  • ComicalMayhemOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 month ago

    Re: Akame Ga Kill. I mean a lot of media can be forgettable but still really enjoyable, but fair. About people’s reactions, I have no other theory to contrast that and tbh it’s quite reasonable. I know the time frames don’t line up but it feels like the manga took a lot of things the anime did and turned it to 11 for the sake of outdoing itself. The giant robot in the anime was just a giant robot, but we don’t even get to see it be a giant robot in the manga, we’re just told “hey this robot is strong” and then it gets eldritchified and we’re told it’s even stronger now. Like, one punch man ok meme. Esdeath goes from being strong in the anime to just overly ridiculously strong to the point where she can create entire armies on her own. Like tf??

    Re: Bumblebee (is it bumblebee or bumbleby?). Thanks for the recommendation! I’ll check it out next time I need something to listen to passively or on long drives. And yeah there’s jack shit for Bumblebee in the show, it’s so bad and forced.

    I hope the deeper examination isn’t turning you off

    You’re telling this to a homestuck enjoyer. I love splashing in puddles too, some of my favorite media isnt all that deep (HS, Overlord, OPM). I do really enjoy RWBY despite its flaws, and in their defense they do well enough for a “turn your brain off and enjoy the jingling keys” show. Besides, I’m currently writing a whole fanfiction about it lol.

    • Unique_Emerald_Sol_I@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 month ago

      I know the time frames don’t line up but it feels like the manga took a lot of things the anime did and turned it to 11 for the sake of outdoing itself.

      Honestly I got the exact same feeling.

      Also I’m not entirely unconvinced that Akame Ga Kill! didn’t have some influence on RWBY (and I’m not talking about the obvious Bitchtits McFrostqueen cosplay in Ice Queendom). Sure, the anime didn’t start airing until 2013, but the manga was running from 2010 so it’s within the realm of possibility that Monty was reading it while developing RWBY.

      Re: Bumblebee (is it bumblebee or bumbleby?).

      It’s kinda whatever. Using “Y” at the end is supposed to be for Yang, but as people are wont to do it got shortened from “bumblebee” to just “(the) bees” (which is also used interchangeably with “wasps” to refer to BMBLB shippers).

      Besides, I’m currently writing a whole fanfiction about it lol.

      Lol that’s fair. A lot of people I meet nowadays are very touchy and all too ready to drop something cold turkey after discovering it has some flaws.

      • ComicalMayhemOP
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        1 month ago

        Also I’m not entirely unconvinced that Akame Ga Kill! didn’t have some influence on RWBY

        Well RWBY is entirely inspired by anime. I wouldn’t be surprised if this is the case but I’m in doubt, I just don’t see the throughline.

        BMBLB

        Wait is that a different ship or the same one? I don’t have any of the ship names stored in my head (except a few).

        A lot of people I meet nowadays are very touchy and all too ready to drop something cold turkey after discovering it has some flaws.

        Sorry to hear. Just because something is flawed doesn’t mean it’s not good or fun, as long as it’s not boring.

        • Unique_Emerald_Sol_I@sh.itjust.works
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 month ago

          BMBLB

          Wait is that a different ship or the same one? I don’t have any of the ship names stored in my head (except a few).

          Lol sorry, that’s just another way to say “Bumblebee” – it’s even the title of a song on the… *checks wiki* V4 soundtrack, though it was never used in the show (because it was a last-minute addition by Jeff Williams with no oversight). Also I forgot: another reason to use the “Bumbleby” spelling is because Yang’s bike is also named Bumblebee.

          I downloaded the “Official r/RWBY Handling (and Shipping) Sheet” from the r/RWBY side-banner a while back (mostly because the google docs spreadsheet was always finicky due to the size of it) so that’s where I get most of my ship name information. There’s always some fun ones in there like “I, Robot” for the Penny/Penny self-ship, Newspaper for the Ruby/Weiss/Blake OT3, or “All according to keikaku” for the Cinder/everyone ship (and, hilariously, “Not according to keikaku” for a Cinder/Dom Ruby). It’s not exactly super accurate (in part because the fandom is fractured) and contains a lot of extraneous information as people wanted to fill in the blank spaces without any ships actually existing for those characters (e.g. I doubt anyone has ever shipped Ren’s dad with Flynt), but it’s still useful and just fun to look thru.

          • ComicalMayhemOP
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            29 days ago

            Not the official RWBY shipping sheet! That’s hilarious, I love it. Do you have a link to it?