Society is a very recent thing. The concept of breakfast is very new again and not even common outside of western societies.
People that “depend” on breakfast are just adjusted to a routine. If you’re in that routine, make the most of it by eating foods that are easy to metabolise and help in that period before your system actually kicks in. Natural sugars, really, fruits, smoothies, etc.
Certainly avoid filling up the stomach with grains and shit, causing your appetite to be low when you should actually need to start eating, about 4 hours after you wake up.
Edit: Sorry. Papers require subs. Just DDG it, though. It’s been covered well.
I think the key thing to ask is, “Did the the recent introduction of civilisation and then being able to have a meal just after waking up suddenly undo a few million years?” It may eventually head that way if breakfasts continue, but we’re talking many more generations through the species.
I think we’re disagreeing on terms, because adjusting to a schedule is exactly what I’m talking about. (That’s also science and our evolution, to be clear.)
Fruits kill my energy and mood in the morning, but grains and protein make me much happier and more energetic. If I wait until lunchtime to eat substantial food, I’m not going to be very productive for the rest of the day. Given that many places with big lunches also have siestas, I can’t imagine I’m alone.
A human who lived before society existed might have been better served by eating mostly later in the day, but they had a very different lifestyle from mine. I want to work (not just at a job, including g chores and working out) pretty consistently from ~8-19, and then I want to rest. They probably wanted to have shorter, more intense bursts of activity sandwiched between periods of inactivity. Eating no breakfast and a big lunch makes me want to do the latter, but sadly, I can’t afford to live like that.
I already explained what you’re saying by social routine. That’s a different topic altogether
We’re so good at adapting to our situations, even voluntary ones. It doesn’t mean they’re efficient. It only takes a few days of habit to release dopamine into a routine pursuit.
There is no way that your body actually gets more from non-nutiricinal inputs, such as grains, in the early hours of metabolism shifting from sleep period. No mamal does and very few species do. What you feel is reward, not energy from nutrition. Your adrenal glands are probably covering it.
You’re getting something, yes. It is beneficial, yes. But if you are consuming in that period, it needs to be highly nutritious to make impact.
A habit (routine) is psychosomatic. The brain operates in that front. It is the same idea as, “I can’t start without my coffee.” Yes, you can. Your body doesn’t actually need or want that at this time of being awake. The only catch with that being caffeine sends inhbitors. Cereals do not. Even when your metabolism is firing later in the day, cereals/grains are basically pointless.
You can disagree, but it’s far more likely that your condition is psychosomatic than being a one-off exceptional blip through our evolution.
I don’t wanna say “Breakfast is a lie” but it kind of is. Even the etymology of the word is a giveaway.
If were not disagreeing on terms, I don’t think your source necessarily supports that, given this, emphasis mine:
Findings regarding energy intake are variable, although the balance of evidence indicates some degree of compensatory feeding later in the day such that overall energy intake is either unaffected or slightly lower when breakfast is omitted from the diet. However, even if net energy intake is reduced, extended morning fasting may not result in expected weight loss due to compensatory adjustments in physical activity thermogenesis. Specifically, we report that both lean and obese adults expended less energy during the morning when remaining in the fasted state than when consuming a prescribed breakfast. Further research is required to examine whether particular health markers may be responsive to breakfast-induced responses of individual components of energy balance irrespective of their net effect on energy balance and therefore body mass.
What I get from that is that people who don’t eat breakfast are expending less energy in the morning, when I want to expend more energy. When I’m not even warming myself to the normal daytime level I’m accustomed to, I can’t concentrate on paperwork. Whether I would on net be just as capable of metabolizing energy and what effect it has on my weight aren’t as relevant to me as whether I can expend energy when I want to.
It could certainly be psychosomatic, but I’ve kept food diaries meticulously before, and if I don’t eat a big breakfast, I don’t compensate later in the day, because I don’t develop an appetite. If I go several days without breakfasts, I will eventually compensate, but not in a way that makes me feel good or like I’m giving my body what it needs.
Coffee is actually something that I frequently consume a lot of and frequently abstain from entirely (I work part time at a coffee shop, so I’ll have 4-8 shots of espresso on days I work and no caffeine at all on days I don’t), without noticing a dependency. It might be there, and I can definitely feel the effects of caffeine, but even when there’s no oat milk at work, I don’t have an issue with doing the things I normally do caffeinated, uncaffeinated.
No, as I said, it’s science and our evolution.
Society is a very recent thing. The concept of breakfast is very new again and not even common outside of western societies.
People that “depend” on breakfast are just adjusted to a routine. If you’re in that routine, make the most of it by eating foods that are easy to metabolise and help in that period before your system actually kicks in. Natural sugars, really, fruits, smoothies, etc.
Certainly avoid filling up the stomach with grains and shit, causing your appetite to be low when you should actually need to start eating, about 4 hours after you wake up.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27292940/
Edit: Sorry. Papers require subs. Just DDG it, though. It’s been covered well.
I think the key thing to ask is, “Did the the recent introduction of civilisation and then being able to have a meal just after waking up suddenly undo a few million years?” It may eventually head that way if breakfasts continue, but we’re talking many more generations through the species.
I think we’re disagreeing on terms, because adjusting to a schedule is exactly what I’m talking about. (That’s also science and our evolution, to be clear.)
Fruits kill my energy and mood in the morning, but grains and protein make me much happier and more energetic. If I wait until lunchtime to eat substantial food, I’m not going to be very productive for the rest of the day. Given that many places with big lunches also have siestas, I can’t imagine I’m alone.
A human who lived before society existed might have been better served by eating mostly later in the day, but they had a very different lifestyle from mine. I want to work (not just at a job, including g chores and working out) pretty consistently from ~8-19, and then I want to rest. They probably wanted to have shorter, more intense bursts of activity sandwiched between periods of inactivity. Eating no breakfast and a big lunch makes me want to do the latter, but sadly, I can’t afford to live like that.
We’re not disagreeing on terms.
I already explained what you’re saying by social routine. That’s a different topic altogether
We’re so good at adapting to our situations, even voluntary ones. It doesn’t mean they’re efficient. It only takes a few days of habit to release dopamine into a routine pursuit.
There is no way that your body actually gets more from non-nutiricinal inputs, such as grains, in the early hours of metabolism shifting from sleep period. No mamal does and very few species do. What you feel is reward, not energy from nutrition. Your adrenal glands are probably covering it.
You’re getting something, yes. It is beneficial, yes. But if you are consuming in that period, it needs to be highly nutritious to make impact.
A habit (routine) is psychosomatic. The brain operates in that front. It is the same idea as, “I can’t start without my coffee.” Yes, you can. Your body doesn’t actually need or want that at this time of being awake. The only catch with that being caffeine sends inhbitors. Cereals do not. Even when your metabolism is firing later in the day, cereals/grains are basically pointless.
You can disagree, but it’s far more likely that your condition is psychosomatic than being a one-off exceptional blip through our evolution.
I don’t wanna say “Breakfast is a lie” but it kind of is. Even the etymology of the word is a giveaway.
If were not disagreeing on terms, I don’t think your source necessarily supports that, given this, emphasis mine:
What I get from that is that people who don’t eat breakfast are expending less energy in the morning, when I want to expend more energy. When I’m not even warming myself to the normal daytime level I’m accustomed to, I can’t concentrate on paperwork. Whether I would on net be just as capable of metabolizing energy and what effect it has on my weight aren’t as relevant to me as whether I can expend energy when I want to.
It could certainly be psychosomatic, but I’ve kept food diaries meticulously before, and if I don’t eat a big breakfast, I don’t compensate later in the day, because I don’t develop an appetite. If I go several days without breakfasts, I will eventually compensate, but not in a way that makes me feel good or like I’m giving my body what it needs.
Coffee is actually something that I frequently consume a lot of and frequently abstain from entirely (I work part time at a coffee shop, so I’ll have 4-8 shots of espresso on days I work and no caffeine at all on days I don’t), without noticing a dependency. It might be there, and I can definitely feel the effects of caffeine, but even when there’s no oat milk at work, I don’t have an issue with doing the things I normally do caffeinated, uncaffeinated.