Their concerns are valid, I think. So are the student’s. Lots of teachers also support the protests, they know full well the conditions they have to work under.
I am in (university) education in France. By and wide, educators absolutely support the protests. They also would like to have the time to educate. Roughly half of the planned curriculum has been covered for this semester. This is including online material, that we all know is not as effective as in person teachings. But what is the way out?
The government is on its way out, whatever they promise will have to be maintained by the incoming government - so no promise is trustworthy right now.
Exams are closing in and what does it even mean to grade over a semester with half of the lessons having been canceled?
Many questions, a lot of insecurity, but also the feeling that the situation is untenable. In my university, a previously mandatory course had to be canceled because the professor was sick for months. There was just no spare room out of a department of 70 full time professors for one of them to be sick more than a couple of days. How can you keep going on? The university brass keep saying that “maybe next year” there will be funding… but they have been saying it for a decade!
Do we all know online lessons are not as effective? From my corona experience it was the teacher’s fails to not agree to one format. One decided to teach on twitch with videos removed after a few days/hours. One decided to require soft/hardware not available to students because lab was closed. The one who made the YT vids was the best among them. There’s even an online plattform which teaches A level contents with videos. Allowed me to redo A level math in a week.
Especially in uni where classrooms have up to 100-500 students this is such a bs take. In my school carrer it was utterly rare that students asked questions when they didnt understand topics and if they did, teachers half assedly rephrased their explanations and i had to look up things at home anyway. With 25+ students, if everyone was honest with their understanding level and ask questions in class, you’d probably not even cover half of the curriculum.
But yes, lets label online learning as bad procedure instead of commuting 1+ hour to the schools with bad teachers, non peer reviewed schooling material n methods, locked in with 24 other chinpanzees disturbing your concentration.
Online learning is more prone to distractions, so is more likely to negatively affect the weaker students. Online learning is more time consuming to set up and requires more tools than just dropping a video, but the teachers are neither equipped nor remunerated to do this extra work. In person provides feedback from which the teacher can on the fly adjust, that lacks in online learning. Online often reduces interactivity, that in turn affects motivation and concentration.
Overall to simplify: right now, with online classes being demanded without preparation nor support a day in advance… online doesn’t work like this.
To follow up on the class sizes problem, that’s a massive ingredient. Both in person and online classes should still have a ratio of <30 students per class. But that’s not always happening in France, and it’s an ingredient in the protests.
Their concerns are valid, I think. So are the student’s. Lots of teachers also support the protests, they know full well the conditions they have to work under.
I am in (university) education in France. By and wide, educators absolutely support the protests. They also would like to have the time to educate. Roughly half of the planned curriculum has been covered for this semester. This is including online material, that we all know is not as effective as in person teachings. But what is the way out?
The government is on its way out, whatever they promise will have to be maintained by the incoming government - so no promise is trustworthy right now.
Exams are closing in and what does it even mean to grade over a semester with half of the lessons having been canceled?
Many questions, a lot of insecurity, but also the feeling that the situation is untenable. In my university, a previously mandatory course had to be canceled because the professor was sick for months. There was just no spare room out of a department of 70 full time professors for one of them to be sick more than a couple of days. How can you keep going on? The university brass keep saying that “maybe next year” there will be funding… but they have been saying it for a decade!
I rather enjoy watching you French folks not taking shit from these bastards.
Not French myself but I agree!!
Do we all know online lessons are not as effective? From my corona experience it was the teacher’s fails to not agree to one format. One decided to teach on twitch with videos removed after a few days/hours. One decided to require soft/hardware not available to students because lab was closed. The one who made the YT vids was the best among them. There’s even an online plattform which teaches A level contents with videos. Allowed me to redo A level math in a week.
Especially in uni where classrooms have up to 100-500 students this is such a bs take. In my school carrer it was utterly rare that students asked questions when they didnt understand topics and if they did, teachers half assedly rephrased their explanations and i had to look up things at home anyway. With 25+ students, if everyone was honest with their understanding level and ask questions in class, you’d probably not even cover half of the curriculum.
But yes, lets label online learning as bad procedure instead of commuting 1+ hour to the schools with bad teachers, non peer reviewed schooling material n methods, locked in with 24 other chinpanzees disturbing your concentration.
Online learning is more prone to distractions, so is more likely to negatively affect the weaker students. Online learning is more time consuming to set up and requires more tools than just dropping a video, but the teachers are neither equipped nor remunerated to do this extra work. In person provides feedback from which the teacher can on the fly adjust, that lacks in online learning. Online often reduces interactivity, that in turn affects motivation and concentration.
Overall to simplify: right now, with online classes being demanded without preparation nor support a day in advance… online doesn’t work like this.
To follow up on the class sizes problem, that’s a massive ingredient. Both in person and online classes should still have a ratio of <30 students per class. But that’s not always happening in France, and it’s an ingredient in the protests.