I’ll explain the joke since no one else did and it seems needed. It’s a word play: at first it sounds like an insult to furries, but read as intended is actually supporting their preference. The initial comment used the word ‘person’ to mean something like ‘fellow sapient deserving of rights and decency’ but the reply chose to interpret it as ‘literally human’ instead. The point being that while I’m sure they’d prefer to be included in the former meaning of the word, they don’t fully identify with the latter.
I’m not a furry myself and won’t pretend to speak for them, but as a bystander who tries to be polite, I didn’t think it was in poor taste. It’s linguistic ambiguity that’s the main butt of the joke, not furry folks themselves.
no the joke is furries dress up as animals, with the express goal of being seen as the animal they dress up as, rather than human. (not in a dehumanising way, think roleplay way)
So, say human, if you need to make that “joke” —especially if you’re not one of said population. They are people (regardless if an animal of their choice is their preferred identity). They have rights, goals, dreams, and presumably jobs, property, etc. just like the rest of us.
In this era, even kidding about that topic is irresponsible at best. Y’all do you, though.
Fuck, that other place is leaking so hard these days. 🥲🖕🏼😚
you do realise “people” was used because the original comment said people? everyone got the joke apart from you.
Also you do realise saying “human” instead of “people” achieves absolutely nothing? you would have still found a way to be upset about a harmless joke.
And even then, the joke just funnily affirms a furry’s identity in a silly manner. No one was saying or implying furries don’t deserve rights or don’t have them.
infact, making this type of joke on lemmy is the safest place you possibly could. You’re reading too much into it, take a step back and read the tone of the comment.
The person was making a silly, that the furrys were “pretending to not be human” and someone got their panties twisted cuz literal word translation is the only way.
Are you sure about that? Because there doesn’t seem to be a solid consensus about the definition of a person.
Sure, you can go to the dictionary and point to the first definition that pops up. But that’s not the only definition.
Here’s another one:
one (…) that is recognized by law as the subject of rights and duties
And so by declaring that such-and-such a category cannot have personhood, you’re declaring it cannot have rights.
I personally believe in personhood not only for animals, but for ecosystems as well, and for significant natural landmarks such as waterways and geological formations. I believe all these things deserve rights. (Corporations, however, don’t).
Anyway, the core of the debate surrounding personhood is whether the definition should be by inclusion or by exclusion; i.e., “this, this, and this category may be persons; and there may be others” versus “that, that, and that category are not persons; only such-and-such.”
And by declaring that animals cannot have personhood, you are taking an exclusivist approach to personhood. History doesn’t look well on exclusionary personism and its proponents.
Remember that when the fight for animal rights and ecosystem rights begins in earnest.
No dude, I’m pretty sure they’re not, that’s like the whole point.
Hey, it’s the future. You’re gonna have a tough time with that viewpoint. 😅😶
I’ll explain the joke since no one else did and it seems needed. It’s a word play: at first it sounds like an insult to furries, but read as intended is actually supporting their preference. The initial comment used the word ‘person’ to mean something like ‘fellow sapient deserving of rights and decency’ but the reply chose to interpret it as ‘literally human’ instead. The point being that while I’m sure they’d prefer to be included in the former meaning of the word, they don’t fully identify with the latter.
I’m not a furry myself and won’t pretend to speak for them, but as a bystander who tries to be polite, I didn’t think it was in poor taste. It’s linguistic ambiguity that’s the main butt of the joke, not furry folks themselves.
Cool cool.
I think you’ll struggle more in the future with your lack of reading comprehension
Yes, yes, I completely missed the point where you didn’t state that furries weren’t people. My bad. 🤣🖕🏼
no the joke is furries dress up as animals, with the express goal of being seen as the animal they dress up as, rather than human. (not in a dehumanising way, think roleplay way)
So, say human, if you need to make that “joke” —especially if you’re not one of said population. They are people (regardless if an animal of their choice is their preferred identity). They have rights, goals, dreams, and presumably jobs, property, etc. just like the rest of us.
In this era, even kidding about that topic is irresponsible at best. Y’all do you, though.
Fuck, that other place is leaking so hard these days. 🥲🖕🏼😚
you do realise “people” was used because the original comment said people? everyone got the joke apart from you.
Also you do realise saying “human” instead of “people” achieves absolutely nothing? you would have still found a way to be upset about a harmless joke.
And even then, the joke just funnily affirms a furry’s identity in a silly manner. No one was saying or implying furries don’t deserve rights or don’t have them.
infact, making this type of joke on lemmy is the safest place you possibly could. You’re reading too much into it, take a step back and read the tone of the comment.
Yes. Precisely. You did in fact miss their point and meaning.
Personhood for animals solves this debate quite cleanly.
It doesn’t matter whether furries are humans or animals. Either way, still people.
Animals are beings, not people.
Humans are people. That’s the schtick.
That doesn’t make an animal less than.
The person was making a silly, that the furrys were “pretending to not be human” and someone got their panties twisted cuz literal word translation is the only way.
Are you sure about that? Because there doesn’t seem to be a solid consensus about the definition of a person.
Sure, you can go to the dictionary and point to the first definition that pops up. But that’s not the only definition.
Here’s another one:
And so by declaring that such-and-such a category cannot have personhood, you’re declaring it cannot have rights.
I personally believe in personhood not only for animals, but for ecosystems as well, and for significant natural landmarks such as waterways and geological formations. I believe all these things deserve rights. (Corporations, however, don’t).
Anyway, the core of the debate surrounding personhood is whether the definition should be by inclusion or by exclusion; i.e., “this, this, and this category may be persons; and there may be others” versus “that, that, and that category are not persons; only such-and-such.”
And by declaring that animals cannot have personhood, you are taking an exclusivist approach to personhood. History doesn’t look well on exclusionary personism and its proponents.
Remember that when the fight for animal rights and ecosystem rights begins in earnest.
You left out part of your own chosen definition.
The core of this debate is you and the other person having extreme reading comprehension skills.
Way to triple down on your idiocy.
Way to be a redderp. Have fun!