• Windex007
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    50 minutes ago

    Fuck reddit. Like, obviously. Wouldn’t be here if I didn’t think so.

    But there is an uncomfortable reality that even with the boatloads of FREE labor from mods (in itself a giant problem) reddit was never profitable. By the time they IPOd they were almost a billion in the hole.

    Even if you say “lavish salaries” or whatever, it would still be many of hundreds of millions without them.

    It sucks but it is what it is. Collective ownership is great when something generates a surplus. At an ongoing loss? Less fun.

    You gotta understand that VC fucking sucks, too. If it were realistically as likely to fill the budget gaps by literally any other mechanisms, most companies would take the alternatives. Lowering ad vetting, reddit gold, their short lived crypto, highly unpopular staffing decisions (canning my girl Victoria)… None of this put reddit even close to being in the black.

    Wikimedia running ongoing donation drives is the closest alternative, but even that doesn’t come with ownership. Collective ownership can come with the same problems as VC anyways, enough people wanna exit their ownership, they can still drive to an IPO. The additional administrative burden of maintaining a splintered cap table as well becomes an expensive additional burden to an already bleeding organization.

    I’m all about collective ownership. I just understand what that entails, and exactly why it’s not always a rose garden. Again, lovely at a surplus. Very painful at a deficit.

    Fuck reddit, hands down. Fuck them over and over. They deserved to fold long ago.

    Lemmy instances run on charity and FOSS code (also charity). Literally nothing is stopping you or anyone from running an instance as a co-op. ml being a bastion of pure communism STILL doesn’t offer ownership stakes.

    So using that objective reality of how the “hardcore Lemmy communists” don’t even have communal ownership of thier communism platforms I think is telling about the realities of ceding ownership of what you’ve wrought by your own charity. There is no law keeping any ml instance from granting equal shares of instance ownerships. It’s not a law problem or even a philosophy problem, it’s simply a people problem (even among the people who do nothing but extoll the virtues of communism day in and day out).

    I can’t stress enough how ml instances exemplify with absolutely no hint of fucking irony the “all animals are created equal, but some are more equal than others” when literally nothing external is stopping them from just literally adopting a model of communal ownership.

    Or, how you could do it like, tomorrow.

    And again, I can’t stress enough: I genuinely really like the idea of communal ownership. It’s just fucking hard when the thing you communally own is a money pit.