Some GTA 6 physical buyers say their boxes came with no download code or one already redeemed, and with no disc inside, they can't install the game at all.
There were already articles a few days ago about how you could read the product code through the box in certain countries by simply shining a flashlight through it, because the regional distributor cheaped out on the paper inset that would have prevented it.
I’m sure making that knowledge public helped the situation. /s
So, it does kinda make sense. It means R* doesn’t have to make a bunch of different collectors sets, instead they make one and you buy your choice of game in your region. I also don’t doubt R* would’ve charged $100 more for including the game anyways.
A good compromise would be allowing the code to work multiple times but only be installed on one system at a time. This would introduce other issues though as people could cycle through all the number combinations and eventually figure out what codes work and ‘steal’ those games.
Oh I definitely get why they do it, but claiming it’s a cost issue to print all these disks doesn’t make sense when they could implement a similar mechanism with digital-only games. They of course don’t want to because they want to wipe out the second-hand market but pointing stuff out like this leaves them nothing to hide behind.
I guess so. Its not the first game having a code in a box. Its similar to a Steam code, that tie to your account and then can never be used again - its consumed, you become a consumer.
This is actually one of the things where Nintendo is ahead, with the game key carts. While its still a code basically, you still own the cartridge and can sell it to others. Microsoft has a new strategy too. You can pop in your disc on the console, then it ties a digital license it to your account. If anyone else pops the disc in, then you loose the digital license. This makes it possible to sell those games, regardless of if is something on the disc or not.
Uh story time! So like 15 years ago, I bought Napoleon Total War. We didn’t have a games shop in town, so I ordered it online. It was supposed to arrive the next day, but delivery got fucked so it took a week to arrive. I was super excited to finally play the game, only to discover the case didn’t have a CD. It turned out it was just a box, with the plastic stuff to hold a CD, but only with a Steam key i instead. I waited a week to get a physical copy of a game, just to get a key I could’ve bought for the same price directly from Steam…
That’s basically what happens with GTA 6 too. As long as they are upfront about it and you know about it, its fine. Because that is the “contract”. But if you didn’t know, then it sucks and is not okay. Either you didn’t read the fine print (it shouldn’t be a fine print anyway, but a big disclaimer) or they didn’t mention it (which would be illegal, but how to proof that?). I wonder how many don’t know they purchasing a code only, with GTA 6. I also wonder how many even care.
Back then I didn’t even consider the option. I always bought physical copies, and didn’t use Steam at all. It was probably written somewhere, but even if I’d read it, I probably wouldn’t have connected the dots, because why would you ever just want a useless empty plastic case?
I think its important that we make this public, because its also to help those in such a situation. I don’t like hiding issues, because that also means anyone having the issue would not know why and can’t even prevent it. Off course, I completely understand the paradoxical situation here, because if you don’t tell it to the mass, then most people won’t abuse it.
There were already articles a few days ago about how you could read the product code through the box in certain countries by simply shining a flashlight through it, because the regional distributor cheaped out on the paper inset that would have prevented it.
I’m sure making that knowledge public helped the situation. /s
Does that mean that the code can only be used once?
So for instance buying the « physical » version of the game doesn’t allow you to resell it?
Correct.
The physical version is just a glorified collector’s set, even the physical box only gives you the digital version.
Correction: the actual collector’s set doesn’t actually come with the game, digital or physical.
Hahahaha
Sorry for the useless comment but a regular upvote didn’t feel like enough
So, it does kinda make sense. It means R* doesn’t have to make a bunch of different collectors sets, instead they make one and you buy your choice of game in your region. I also don’t doubt R* would’ve charged $100 more for including the game anyways.
I had thought that you would be at least able to resell the code and transfer the licence to someone else…
That’s crazy…
The game looks and sounds great, bit so many things aemre pushing me away from it…
A good compromise would be allowing the code to work multiple times but only be installed on one system at a time. This would introduce other issues though as people could cycle through all the number combinations and eventually figure out what codes work and ‘steal’ those games.
Even better would be just having a disc.
You’re missing the point.
You’re assuming these gaming companies care about their users…
It’s like my copy of wow I purchased 20 years ago. I have the box and game, but seems my account has disappeared and I’d need to repurchase
Oh I definitely get why they do it, but claiming it’s a cost issue to print all these disks doesn’t make sense when they could implement a similar mechanism with digital-only games. They of course don’t want to because they want to wipe out the second-hand market but pointing stuff out like this leaves them nothing to hide behind.
That’s kind of what Nintendo did with their new Virtual game cards.
I guess so. Its not the first game having a code in a box. Its similar to a Steam code, that tie to your account and then can never be used again - its consumed, you become a consumer.
This is actually one of the things where Nintendo is ahead, with the game key carts. While its still a code basically, you still own the cartridge and can sell it to others. Microsoft has a new strategy too. You can pop in your disc on the console, then it ties a digital license it to your account. If anyone else pops the disc in, then you loose the digital license. This makes it possible to sell those games, regardless of if is something on the disc or not.
Uh story time! So like 15 years ago, I bought Napoleon Total War. We didn’t have a games shop in town, so I ordered it online. It was supposed to arrive the next day, but delivery got fucked so it took a week to arrive. I was super excited to finally play the game, only to discover the case didn’t have a CD. It turned out it was just a box, with the plastic stuff to hold a CD, but only with a Steam key i instead. I waited a week to get a physical copy of a game, just to get a key I could’ve bought for the same price directly from Steam…
Ugh that sucks! It was so much more fun going into a games store, browsing the shelves and physically buying a copy.
Hell yeah, love story times. :D
That’s basically what happens with GTA 6 too. As long as they are upfront about it and you know about it, its fine. Because that is the “contract”. But if you didn’t know, then it sucks and is not okay. Either you didn’t read the fine print (it shouldn’t be a fine print anyway, but a big disclaimer) or they didn’t mention it (which would be illegal, but how to proof that?). I wonder how many don’t know they purchasing a code only, with GTA 6. I also wonder how many even care.
Back then I didn’t even consider the option. I always bought physical copies, and didn’t use Steam at all. It was probably written somewhere, but even if I’d read it, I probably wouldn’t have connected the dots, because why would you ever just want a useless empty plastic case?
Nintendo is great if you want to buy nothing but sequels of the same game made 30+ years ago
Also, I owned a wii. Guess who basically needs to re buy all the games if I want to use them on switch
My point was, that there are better ways than a code-in-a-box for digital only games.
I think its important that we make this public, because its also to help those in such a situation. I don’t like hiding issues, because that also means anyone having the issue would not know why and can’t even prevent it. Off course, I completely understand the paradoxical situation here, because if you don’t tell it to the mass, then most people won’t abuse it.