fair tbh. i think it gets muddy when we’re talking about evicting people who were born in israeli-occupied parts of palestine and have no other home, but that’s just decolonisation being a mess in general.
either way, even if it goes as wrong as it can, evicting the colonisers isn’t the same as evicting the jews, even if most colonisers happen to be jewish in this case.
that said, i understand the fear of the oppressed group becoming the oppressor. but given everything that would have to go right for palestine to be free again, ensuring the safety and equal rights of israeli-born jews in a decolonisation event would be significantly easier than stopping the ongoing oppression. and i think it’s also much more important to stand against present oppression than hypothetical future oppression, and not let fears of the latter be the reason we don’t fix the former. none of that is a support for said hypothetical future oppression either, it’s just harm reduction in action.
Palestinians would become oppressors if they for some reason decided to leave Palestine and colonize Congo because the lithium was promised to them 4000 years ago or something. Not if they liberated their homeland of colonizers.
but given everything that would have to go right for palestine to be free again, ensuring the safety and equal rights of israeli-born jews in a decolonisation event would be significantly easier than stopping the ongoing oppression.
Not sure what you mean by that. But Palestinians aren’t responsible for the safety of those colonizing their land nor do I imagine that it would be easier for them to liberate it if they took great care to avoid colonizer casualties.
Like you said I’m sure it will be messy but almost all israelis have a second passport they can magically whip out and suddenly they have another place to call home.
In any case, solving that issue can be done by the whole global community if they want to. No reason Palestinians should be solely responsible for a crisis forced upon them by the entire Western world. Especially if everyone cares so much about the safety of those Israelis colonizers surely they’re willing to then take them as refugees. They can all go have a great time in New York, Miami and Berlin.
afaik around 80% of israelis have been born there. their colonial project has been going for 75 years, that’s a lot of time to make babies who had largely nothing to do with it and were just born into a horrible situation. maybe some are still young enough that they would just follow their parents back home, but you’re definitely gonna have a significant number of full adults there who simply do not have another nationality.
that’s the part where decolonisation gets messy. that’s not to say it shouldn’t happen, but you gotta figure out a fair solution for those people too. but yes, the rest of the world should be involved in it too, especially those countries that have supported israel’s genocide.
They’re born on stolen land and they’re going to give that land back.
Not only are they born on the stolen land, they’ve actively kept the Apartheid and misery of Palestinians going escalating into the current genocide. And are actively voting and participating militarily for more Apartheid, genocide and colonization.
They have made zero effort to undo any of the injustices of their ancestors and have only doubled down.
Here’s the fair solution: 100% for Palestinians. 0% for Israelis.
are you american by any chance? just for the stolen land thing.
look, i’m fully pro-palestine, but i don’t think openly calling for a violation of udhr article 15 is a great look for the movement. the solution, if we ever get there, will be messy and imperfect, but the deportation of people born in israeli-occupied palestine to some random country they’ve never lived in and have never had any connection to absolutely should not be part of it. that is just making the same mistake israeli colonisers are making, of cleaning the land of the undesirables to build the state you wish to see on it.
you’re only proving the diet zionist here right, the one above that i tried to fight off on your post.
yes, israelis need to be held accountable for their crimes against palestine, and yes, that does include israeli-born ones as well. the vast majority of adult second or third gen israelis, those who you can’t just send off to go with their parents to a different country, have indeed contributed to the zionist project. but holding them accountable does not mean sending them to some random country.
and i’m sorry but i really don’t vibe with the idea of being born in sin. people are born innocent and remain innocent until they commit crimes.
i’m very explicitly not saying this is a higher priority than restoring the integrity of palestine, or that the liberation and decolonisation of palestine can only happen once it can be perfect. it is in fact a form of discrimination to demand that errors should only ever be made in one direction. but that is not a licence to make errors on purpose, or pretend there are none to be made. it’s called harm reduction, not harm elimination, for a reason: you cannot get it perfect. the best you can strive for is to make things fair, and make them less bad.
it’s not a failure to end up with some harm remaining, but it is actively harmful to deny it because it does not spark joy.
fair tbh. i think it gets muddy when we’re talking about evicting people who were born in israeli-occupied parts of palestine and have no other home, but that’s just decolonisation being a mess in general.
either way, even if it goes as wrong as it can, evicting the colonisers isn’t the same as evicting the jews, even if most colonisers happen to be jewish in this case.
that said, i understand the fear of the oppressed group becoming the oppressor. but given everything that would have to go right for palestine to be free again, ensuring the safety and equal rights of israeli-born jews in a decolonisation event would be significantly easier than stopping the ongoing oppression. and i think it’s also much more important to stand against present oppression than hypothetical future oppression, and not let fears of the latter be the reason we don’t fix the former. none of that is a support for said hypothetical future oppression either, it’s just harm reduction in action.
Palestinians would become oppressors if they for some reason decided to leave Palestine and colonize Congo because the lithium was promised to them 4000 years ago or something. Not if they liberated their homeland of colonizers.
Not sure what you mean by that. But Palestinians aren’t responsible for the safety of those colonizing their land nor do I imagine that it would be easier for them to liberate it if they took great care to avoid colonizer casualties.
Like you said I’m sure it will be messy but almost all israelis have a second passport they can magically whip out and suddenly they have another place to call home.
In any case, solving that issue can be done by the whole global community if they want to. No reason Palestinians should be solely responsible for a crisis forced upon them by the entire Western world. Especially if everyone cares so much about the safety of those Israelis colonizers surely they’re willing to then take them as refugees. They can all go have a great time in New York, Miami and Berlin.
afaik around 80% of israelis have been born there. their colonial project has been going for 75 years, that’s a lot of time to make babies who had largely nothing to do with it and were just born into a horrible situation. maybe some are still young enough that they would just follow their parents back home, but you’re definitely gonna have a significant number of full adults there who simply do not have another nationality.
that’s the part where decolonisation gets messy. that’s not to say it shouldn’t happen, but you gotta figure out a fair solution for those people too. but yes, the rest of the world should be involved in it too, especially those countries that have supported israel’s genocide.
They’re born on stolen land and they’re going to give that land back.
Not only are they born on the stolen land, they’ve actively kept the Apartheid and misery of Palestinians going escalating into the current genocide. And are actively voting and participating militarily for more Apartheid, genocide and colonization.
They have made zero effort to undo any of the injustices of their ancestors and have only doubled down.
Here’s the fair solution: 100% for Palestinians. 0% for Israelis.
are you american by any chance? just for the stolen land thing.
look, i’m fully pro-palestine, but i don’t think openly calling for a violation of udhr article 15 is a great look for the movement. the solution, if we ever get there, will be messy and imperfect, but the deportation of people born in israeli-occupied palestine to some random country they’ve never lived in and have never had any connection to absolutely should not be part of it. that is just making the same mistake israeli colonisers are making, of cleaning the land of the undesirables to build the state you wish to see on it.
you’re only proving the diet zionist here right, the one above that i tried to fight off on your post.
yes, israelis need to be held accountable for their crimes against palestine, and yes, that does include israeli-born ones as well. the vast majority of adult second or third gen israelis, those who you can’t just send off to go with their parents to a different country, have indeed contributed to the zionist project. but holding them accountable does not mean sending them to some random country.
and i’m sorry but i really don’t vibe with the idea of being born in sin. people are born innocent and remain innocent until they commit crimes.
i’m very explicitly not saying this is a higher priority than restoring the integrity of palestine, or that the liberation and decolonisation of palestine can only happen once it can be perfect. it is in fact a form of discrimination to demand that errors should only ever be made in one direction. but that is not a licence to make errors on purpose, or pretend there are none to be made. it’s called harm reduction, not harm elimination, for a reason: you cannot get it perfect. the best you can strive for is to make things fair, and make them less bad.
it’s not a failure to end up with some harm remaining, but it is actively harmful to deny it because it does not spark joy.