Religious dogma creates and controls religious thought. That’s its purpose. If course not all religious people are fully caught up in the dogma, but all are influenced by it in one way or another.
The fact that scientists can also have deeply held religious beliefs does not prove the religion. Their worthwhile and lasting contributions are scientific, if their philosophy helped them get there, that’s cool, but the new ideas are what matter and organized religion has none to offer.
The Friedmann example is a good one, I think that his work was abstract enough to not directly threaten religious dogma in the same way that say a heliocentric solar system did. I suppose it really comes down to what is perceived as poking holes in the story vs supporting it, which is of course relative.
You can’t give me gods trajectory orbiting Mars, or any actual direct evidence or data that could be independently observed, because proving god is proving a negative, it’s certainty in an abstract concept completely absent in measurable reality.
You can see god everywhere and that’s fine, but any observation truly independent of religious thought/dogma will conclude that there is no proof.
it is true that having deeply held beliefs while doing science doesn’t prove god but the scientific work of religious scholars is not about proving god but trying to better understand.
and objective truth is the end goal of the scientific method; so there are no alignment problems as long as both are just seeking truth and understanding.
you are correct, no one has yet found a multidimensional solution to the location of god but the work in multidimensional analysis is useful outside of faith.
we just established that the proof would require a greater understanding first and we just simply have not achieved the level of scientific knowledge and understanding required yet.
Dogma not fully capturing the heart and mind of each religious person does not mean it isnt pervasive and effective within religious schools of thought, both things can be true. That’s how scientists who are religious can step outside their established religious thought to do good and useful work.
I’m glad we seem to agree that the science is useful, when applied outside of faith. You seem however to be working backward from your conclusion, which isn’t at all scientific.
Religious dogma creates and controls religious thought. That’s its purpose. If course not all religious people are fully caught up in the dogma, but all are influenced by it in one way or another.
The fact that scientists can also have deeply held religious beliefs does not prove the religion. Their worthwhile and lasting contributions are scientific, if their philosophy helped them get there, that’s cool, but the new ideas are what matter and organized religion has none to offer.
The Friedmann example is a good one, I think that his work was abstract enough to not directly threaten religious dogma in the same way that say a heliocentric solar system did. I suppose it really comes down to what is perceived as poking holes in the story vs supporting it, which is of course relative.
You can’t give me gods trajectory orbiting Mars, or any actual direct evidence or data that could be independently observed, because proving god is proving a negative, it’s certainty in an abstract concept completely absent in measurable reality.
You can see god everywhere and that’s fine, but any observation truly independent of religious thought/dogma will conclude that there is no proof.
your own sentence refuted itself.
it is true that having deeply held beliefs while doing science doesn’t prove god but the scientific work of religious scholars is not about proving god but trying to better understand.
and objective truth is the end goal of the scientific method; so there are no alignment problems as long as both are just seeking truth and understanding.
you are correct, no one has yet found a multidimensional solution to the location of god but the work in multidimensional analysis is useful outside of faith.
we just established that the proof would require a greater understanding first and we just simply have not achieved the level of scientific knowledge and understanding required yet.
Dogma not fully capturing the heart and mind of each religious person does not mean it isnt pervasive and effective within religious schools of thought, both things can be true. That’s how scientists who are religious can step outside their established religious thought to do good and useful work.
I’m glad we seem to agree that the science is useful, when applied outside of faith. You seem however to be working backward from your conclusion, which isn’t at all scientific.