Locked: people are getting too heated over a silly meme.

Plus people keep reporting this meme as not being ‘archeology’… but other “successful” history meme posted here were never reported : https://sopuli.xyz/post/54498758, https://sopuli.xyz/post/53153470, https://sopuli.xyz/post/52558875

So, may be, some people, on this one, are not acting in good faith.

This is a community about archeology, and sometime history. That mean official history (wiki is a good start).

Yeah history might be wrong sometime, biased, and written by the victor. If you contradict its teaching, go to an university and bring your proof there. A lost forum in a remote corner of the internet, wont help in anything.

  • undergroundoverground
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    2 days ago

    He was a dictator by any standard of measurement. Why tell such appalling lies? You have a limited understanding of what fascism is and all the forms it can take. Totalitarianism, like the kind found in the soviet union, is incompatible with socialism. Try reading something on it that was written after the 1970s.

    I have no western supremacist view. That’s just more things you’ve made up. I just like socialism enough to know when people are lying about it. Again, your tankie BS won’t work on me.

    • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      edit-2
      2 days ago

      Not even the CIA believed Stalin was a dictator:

      The CIA report speaks to your misconceptions directly as a result of not knowing how the USSR was structured. For more on Stalin, I recommend Stalin: History and Critique of a Black Legend by Domenico Losurdo. Losurdo uses near-exclusively western and anti-communist sources in this one.

      The USSR was not “totalitarian.” You keep repeating this dogma like it means anything, but you have absolutely nothing to counter the demonstrations of working class power I have described. Guess what? Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance is from 2023, and backs up what I’ve described. The opening of the Soviet archives confirms much of what the communists have said all along, like Pat Sloan’s Soviet Democracy and Anna Louise Strong’s reporting in This Soviet World.

      Fascism is capitalism with the illusion of bourgeois democracy replaced with open gangsterism by the capitalist class. It isn’t any system you don’t happen to like.

      You refuse to confront your own misconceptions because to do so would be to admit that the west isn’t the least bad system around. You may want socialism, but you’re happier knowing that nobody else has managed to build it without you. This is why you have chauvanist views, and why you need to be serious. Please present any counter, because at this point I’ve delivered sober fact after fact for you while you bury your head in the sand, yelling “tankie.”

      • undergroundoverground
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        2 days ago

        He was a dictator by the definition of the word.

        I would love for someone to build socialism with or without me. I don’t think I’d even be able to help make socialism happen to be honest. So, I don’t see why it would need me. I don’t think the western system is the least bad system and, even if it was, I wouldn’t see that as a valid excuse for it. Just more nonsense you’ve made up and undoubtedly throw at anyone who sees the soviet union for the fascist hell hole it was.

        the problem is, you think your outdated BS deserves a real rebuttal and it just doesn’t. Just because it was more materialistic and atheistic, it doesn’t mean it doesn’t fit a modern understanding of fascism and all the forms it can take.

        • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          arrow-down
          2
          ·
          2 days ago

          Can you explain what I made up? Everything I said is backed up with primary sources, secondary sources, and archival evidence. I provided this evidence. I’m trying to guess at and tease out any coherent point from your end, because you’ve provided none to go off of. How is communism outdated? Is 2023 too outdated for you, and if so, why mention the 1970s as a good point to start? Why do you say Stalin was a dictator, when even the CIA said he wasn’t? I don’t need a rebuttal from you, because I know you have nothing to go off of. I’d just like you to do some introspection and actually think about what you’re talking about, not just labeling anything you don’t like as fascist and sticking your head in the sand yelling “tankie.”

          • undergroundoverground
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            3
            arrow-down
            2
            ·
            2 days ago

            Made up about me, as thr words I used clearly meant.

            Let’s see your true colours: were the gulags bad? Was it wrong to violently put down the Hungarian revolution of 1956?

            • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              3
              arrow-down
              1
              ·
              2 days ago

              As I said, you haven’t given me much to go off of, when all you do is repeat slogans it’s difficult to piece together what your actual perspective is. If you’d participate a bit more, then it would be easier.

              As for the GULAG administration, what aspects specifically? Much of the soviet prison system was progressive even by today’s standards. Prisoners were paid wages similar to what they’d get outside, there was vacation time, even handcuffs were seen as barbaric. Not all of the prison system was progressive, though, and conditions would be quite backward compared to what we’d want today. You can read Russian Justice for a more thorough overview of the soviet justice system.

              It was correct to put down the fascists in Hungary. The Hungarian revolt in 1956 was infested with anti-semitic pograms. MI6 funded, supplied, and trained the Hungarian counter-revolutionaries. These counter-revolutionaries were allied with fascists who were lynching Jewish people and Communists. The Truth About Hungary by Herbert Aptheker heavily relies on citing western sources like the New York Times. Aptheker backs up his claims heavily.

              "The special correspondent of the Yugoslav paper, Politika, (Nov. 13, 1956) describing the events of those days, said that the homes of Communists were marked with a white cross and those of Jews with a black cross, to serve as signs for the extermination squads. “There is no longer any room for doubt,” said the Yugoslav reporter, “it is an example of classic Hungarian fascism and of White Terror. The information,” continued this writer, “coming from the provinces tells how in certain places Communists were having their eyes put out, their ears cut off, and that they were being killed in the most terrible ways.”

              “But the forces of reaction were rapidly consolidating their power and pushing forward on the top levels, while in the streets the blood of scores of massacred Communists, Jews, and progressives was flowing.”

              “Some of the reports reaching Warsaw from Budapest today caused considerable concern. These reports told of massacres of Communists and Jews by what were described as 'Fascist elements’ …” (N.Y. Times, Nov. 1. 1956)

              “The evidence is conclusive that the entry of Soviet troops into Budapest stopped the execution of scores, perhaps thousands of Jews, for by the end of October and early November, anti-Semtic pogroms - hallmark of unbridled fascistic terror - were making their appearance, after an absence of some ten years, within Hungary.”

              "A correspondent of the Israeli newspaper Maariv (Tel Aviv) reported:

              During the uprising a number of former Nazis were released from prison and other former Nazis came to Hungary from Salzburg . . . I met them at the border . . . I saw anti-Semitic posters in Budapest . . . On the walls, street lights, streetcars, you saw inscriptions reading: “Down with Jew Gero!” “Down with Jew Rakosi!” or just simply “down with the Jews!”

              Leading rabbinical circles in New York received a cable early in November from corresponding circles in Vienna that “Jewish blood is being shed by the rebels in Hungary.” Very much later-in February, 1957-the World Jewish Congress reported that “anti-Semitic excesses occurred in more than twenty villages and smaller provincial towns during the October-November revolt.” This occurred, according to this very conservative body, because “fascist and anti-Semitic groups had apparently seized the opportunity, presented by the absence of a central authority, to come to the surface.” Many among the Jewish refugees from Hungary, the report continued, had fled from this anti-Semitic pogrom-like atmosphere (N.Y. Times, Feb. 15, 1957). This confirmed the earlier report made by the British Rabbi, R. Pozner, who, after touring refugee camps, declared that “the majority of Jews who left Hungary did so for fear of the Hungarians and not the Russians.” The Paris Jewish newspaper, Naye Presse, asserted that Jewish refugees in France claimed quite generally that Soviet soldiers had saved their lives."

              Further, the CIA also backed Hungarian resistance forces:

              Prague in 1968 was a similar fascist uprising in both cases there were some elements of progressive protest, but these were greatly overshadowed by the fascist movements. Dubcek wanted to sell out to the IMF, and restore capitalism. The idea that any of this was about “democracy” or “freedom” is silly, it was always about Cold War tactics to destabilize socialism.

              TL;DR imagine if the January 6th rioters were armed and trained by foreign governments, started lynching officials and Jewish people, and the US sent in the army to put down the insurrection. The MAGA chuds would claim that it was about “freedom” and “democracy,” but we all know that they just wanted Trump in office.

              • undergroundoverground
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                arrow-down
                3
                ·
                2 days ago

                Why would I participate more openly with the kind of person who would attempt to defend to soviet gulags? I saw you coming from a mile away.

                And the big one: was it wrong to violently put down the Hungarian revolution of 1956?

                • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  3
                  ·
                  2 days ago

                  I defended the progressive elements of the soviet justice system, while saying we should learn from their mistakes. A much better way of looking at society than a Marvel-esque good vs. evil, and I provided sources as well. As for Hungary, re-read my reply, I edited it.

                  • undergroundoverground
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    arrow-down
                    3
                    ·
                    2 days ago

                    Over a million people died in the soviet gulags. It doesn’t matter that they were a bit better than the nazi labour camps (not the nazis death camps which were, of course, far worse). It was an indefenceable institution, predominantly used to silence anyone who disagreed with the totalitarian regime but that didn’t stop you trying.

                    Not everyone, including other communists, agrees with your interpretation of the Hungarian revolution and they have compelling evidence too, as well you know. So, despite literally being the exact kind of person the term tankie derived from, you still take issue with it? What’s that about? Did you just presume I didn’t know its origin or something?

                    What you’ve shown is that you don’t care if it was bad or good. You’ll defend it regardless and that tells people all they need to know.

    • chloroken@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      2 days ago

      Telling Cowbee he has a “limited understanding of fascism” is wild. You are so outrageously outgunned. And you are so-obviously a chauvinistic, western, imperialist thinker, I’m not sure why you would hide from what’s apparent. Own your shit, reactionary.