Wellington (AFP) – The mayor of New Zealand’s largest city said democracy has “had its day” and it was time to try another form of government while lauding China’s one-party system.
Auckland’s Mayor Wayne Brown told media outlet Stuff he had watched New Zealand’s recent election during a trip to the Chinese mega-city of Guangzhou.
“I don’t know what’s going on in New Zealand,” he said in the interview published on Tuesday.
“It’s an unfathomable system… and look at the election in America… produced a sort of non-working government. Europe hasn’t had a good election for years.”
“Democracy’s had its day. It’s time for something else, really,” he added.
New Zealand went to the polls this month but the result remains too close to call, with coalition negotiations expected to begin when final results are released on November 27.
Asked what his proposed alternative to democracy would be, Brown said that he did not want to get involved in ideology.
“What’s working? China’s working. You know, in terms of economic growth and prosperity,” he said.
China’s growth has slowed in recent years as the world’s second-largest economy struggles to prop up domestic demand and reverse a spending slump.
Beijing is also accused of widespread rights violations, including against ethnic minorities, with freedom of expression curtailed and any opposition to its ruling Communist Party stamped out.
Brown’s comments sparked a rare rebuke from Washington’s ambassador in Wellington Jared Novelly.
“I suppose New Zealand government requires a minimum level of intelligence to receive an intelligence briefing; it’s obvious from his statements the mayor hasn’t made the cut,” Novelly said on X.
“The United States and New Zealand didn’t build two successful democracies by deciding that giving people a say was too much trouble.”
He then told state broadcaster RNZ that it seemed Brown had been “captured” by China.
He said he welcomed the opportunity to talk with the mayor, “but you know, it might be tough to get through the red flag on his door”.
New Zealand is a member of the “Five Eyes” intelligence-sharing alliance alongside the United States, Britain, Canada and Australia.
The island nation has been criticised for taking a softer line on China – putting its trading relationship ahead of its allies’ security concerns.
However, Wellington’s stance has at times publicly hardened against Beijing in recent years with an August intelligence agency report accusing China of espionage, which its embassy strongly denied.
Brown has been mayor of Auckland since 2022 and is known for incendiary outbursts, including referring to a journalist of Indian descent as a “Muslim terrorist”.


When was the last time they elected someone explicitly not endorsed by the Party? Just curious what would happen if someone tried to campaign on the platform “Xi and the Party are bad, we should abolish the government in Beijing”.
Oh that’s right, the people who think that end up in jail for thinking the “wrong thoughts” (as determined by the fascists in charge)
They wouldn’t be elected in the first place, because the overwhelming majority of Chinese society supports their socialist system and the CPC. The CPC prevents pro-capitalist elements from forming political power that could overturn socialism, and the overwhelming majority don’t have any issue with that whatsoever. Further, no idea what you mean by “fascist,” fascism isn’t “government you don’t like.” It’s capitalism run in a gangster fashion, where capitalists openly dominate the economy and the state. The opposite is the case in China.
I think a presumption that everyone agrees and therefore there would be no dissent is pretty disingenuous. You’re proposing a self fulfilling prophecy of “there is no dissent so everyone supports the state but the state crushes all dissent so there is no dissent”. Do you see how ridiculous that sounds? There is no such thing as perfect agreement, especially in the worlds most populous country, and anyone saying otherwise is lying to you.
Fascism has no requirement to be capitalist. Fascism is a system of government where all power is consolidated under a single leader. Xi Jinping is a single leader with all official power (state and economical) in China. China can absolutely be described as “Fascist”, regardless of my personal feelings. The US is also quickly approaching fascism, but there is still a thin veneer of people having a say in their government holding them back from full-on fascism.
I never said everyone agrees, I said nobody opposing the socialist system would win because it’s overwhelmingly popular. I’m not just pulling popular support out of a hat, it’s well documented:
That’s also not what fascism is, nor is it what China actually operates like anyways. Fascism historically has arisen in Italy, Nazi Germany, etc. as open gangsterism from the capitalist class ripping away existing bourgeois democratic systems. It seems you’re trying to use it as a stand-in for “dictatorship,” but that’s also not how China operates. Xi Jinping doesn’t have absolute power, and in fact the actual distribution of power among leadership is much more horizontal than in many western countries.
I think you should make it a habit of doing research into topics before discussing them so confidently.