I waited a bit to put a top level reply on this because I wanted to go home and mess with my selection of cameras to ensure I wasn’t grossly misremembering something and I didn’t have any of them on me at work. For shame, for shame, I know.
Here is the headline that matters: I, unlike many of the commenters here, am going to freely admit that any speculating I do here is me completely talking out of my ass. The truth of it is that we will never know the actual answer for this quirk except in the unlikely event that a Sony engineer happens to pass by our humble community or possibly if somebody manages to corner one of them and nail him down to an answer somehow.
My take on the matter is that the forced card reformat smells like an artificial limitation and is either likely due to some combination of Sony flavored ineptitude and/or apathy, or is equally likely to be a deliberate and completely on brand customer hostile action on their part in true Sony tradition. Most likely as some manner of limp-dicked attempt at content region locking.
You know, coming from the guys who are infamous for being instrumental in insisting that region locking must be written right into the DVD specification, among other things, over and above the inherent NTSC/PAL/SECAM incompatibilities already inherent in all of those flavors of gear.
I would 100% believe that the camera is not capable of outputting NTSC video when it’s in PAL mode and vise versa for some manner of obscure technical or software limitation. Locking out the video frame rates that are incompatible with your region likewise makes sense, even if only to not give the user enough rope to hang himself. And with the best will in the world, unless the user is deliberately hooking their camera up to some manner of multisync display device it’s not going to work if you plug it into something from the wrong region anyway, especially if you’re doing it over composite.
But the formatting your memory card thing feels like one of those extra special Sony flavored fuck-yous, right up there with rootkits on their music CDs, MagicGate… hell, even SonicStage, and all the rest of it.
So for the record this is a Canon household. I do not have a kind spot anywhere in my heart for Sony and for myriad reasons I never will.
However.
My ancient Powershot SX130 IS: Allows me to freely switch between NTSC and PAL, right there in the menu. When I exit the menu, it is already active. No reboot required, no reformat required.
My R10: Again allows me to switch between NTSC and PAL, right there in the menu. No reboot, no reformat. This camera can output externally solely in HDMI, for whatever it’s worth.
My EOS 40D: Wouldn’t you know it, this also allows me to switch between NTSC and PAL. No reboot, no reformat. But the sole effect this has as far as I can tell is changing the flavor of the analog video output via the barrel jack on the side.
Just for grins sies I took a short video clip of the blinkenlights inside my computer tower with both my SX130 and my R10 in NTSC mode, then switched to PAL and checked if I could play it back. The answer is yes, no problem. (And the 40D actually doesn’t have a dedicated video mode, believe it or not, so we don’t get a third data point.) The R10 does change its offering of recording frame rates depending on whether you have it set to NTSC or PAL, but the SX130 is not that complicated and doesn’t allow you to change its inbuilt video framerate, resolution, or aspect ratio at all. But it still works either way.
So in the absence of a first hand source, we can describe it thusly: Incompetence, indifference, or malice. Pick any three.
I waited a bit to put a top level reply on this because I wanted to go home and mess with my selection of cameras to ensure I wasn’t grossly misremembering something and I didn’t have any of them on me at work. For shame, for shame, I know.
Here is the headline that matters: I, unlike many of the commenters here, am going to freely admit that any speculating I do here is me completely talking out of my ass. The truth of it is that we will never know the actual answer for this quirk except in the unlikely event that a Sony engineer happens to pass by our humble community or possibly if somebody manages to corner one of them and nail him down to an answer somehow.
My take on the matter is that the forced card reformat smells like an artificial limitation and is either likely due to some combination of Sony flavored ineptitude and/or apathy, or is equally likely to be a deliberate and completely on brand customer hostile action on their part in true Sony tradition. Most likely as some manner of limp-dicked attempt at content region locking.
You know, coming from the guys who are infamous for being instrumental in insisting that region locking must be written right into the DVD specification, among other things, over and above the inherent NTSC/PAL/SECAM incompatibilities already inherent in all of those flavors of gear.
I would 100% believe that the camera is not capable of outputting NTSC video when it’s in PAL mode and vise versa for some manner of obscure technical or software limitation. Locking out the video frame rates that are incompatible with your region likewise makes sense, even if only to not give the user enough rope to hang himself. And with the best will in the world, unless the user is deliberately hooking their camera up to some manner of multisync display device it’s not going to work if you plug it into something from the wrong region anyway, especially if you’re doing it over composite.
But the formatting your memory card thing feels like one of those extra special Sony flavored fuck-yous, right up there with rootkits on their music CDs, MagicGate… hell, even SonicStage, and all the rest of it.
So for the record this is a Canon household. I do not have a kind spot anywhere in my heart for Sony and for myriad reasons I never will.
However.
My ancient Powershot SX130 IS: Allows me to freely switch between NTSC and PAL, right there in the menu. When I exit the menu, it is already active. No reboot required, no reformat required.
My R10: Again allows me to switch between NTSC and PAL, right there in the menu. No reboot, no reformat. This camera can output externally solely in HDMI, for whatever it’s worth.
My EOS 40D: Wouldn’t you know it, this also allows me to switch between NTSC and PAL. No reboot, no reformat. But the sole effect this has as far as I can tell is changing the flavor of the analog video output via the barrel jack on the side.
Just for grins sies I took a short video clip of the blinkenlights inside my computer tower with both my SX130 and my R10 in NTSC mode, then switched to PAL and checked if I could play it back. The answer is yes, no problem. (And the 40D actually doesn’t have a dedicated video mode, believe it or not, so we don’t get a third data point.) The R10 does change its offering of recording frame rates depending on whether you have it set to NTSC or PAL, but the SX130 is not that complicated and doesn’t allow you to change its inbuilt video framerate, resolution, or aspect ratio at all. But it still works either way.
So in the absence of a first hand source, we can describe it thusly: Incompetence, indifference, or malice. Pick any three.