That’s a very convenient excuse and records are only as good as the people that keep them and the soviets were well known to doctor and forge documents and evidence.
You assume I haven’t read rather than I have but I simply disagree with you.
I’m aware no one wanted to help the soviets, no one had to but to say oh they joined the devil to lead the revolt from behind the front lines is absurd. You don’t get points for not being able to reign in your bullshit long enough for people to give a shit about you and yeah that applies just as well today as it did then.
I said internal for a reason. The archives, what’s left of them, are far more open than they used to be. People don’t write propaganda in their internal documentation because it isn’t meant for public eyes. They have no reason to lie to themselves. Please read this peer reviewed academic text regarding our specific discussion. The author is an expert in soviet military history and the great patriotic war in general. I assure you it is interesting and worth reading. I assumed you have not read because your opinion is no longer accepted by modern historiography. This is not something that is seriously debated anymore.
People write fraudulent internal documents all the time, your stance is predicated on soviets who were known to have bullshit government documents somehow have accurate documents in this case.
Sure people don’t lie to themselves, Trump is the best president ever I guess… Right? Or are we gonna back off that?
if you have read a United States document then it was not internal. you and I both have no fucking idea what internal US documents look like right now. If you have seen a document claiming that trump is the best president ever and the economy is great then it is because that by definition was not an internal document. besides, my argument pales in comparison to the professor and prolific writer I linked. Please read the modern historical discussion regarding this topic. If you want more resources I would be happy to link them. I am otherwise disengaging as you seem more interested in defending an ideological position than engaging with history.
edit: yes internal documents are still subject to bias and I am not suggesting otherwise. The idea that they are subject to the sort of extreme bias you are suggesting however is very very rarely true and easy to see through when that is the case once compared with other historical evidence.
That’s a very convenient excuse and records are only as good as the people that keep them and the soviets were well known to doctor and forge documents and evidence.
You assume I haven’t read rather than I have but I simply disagree with you.
I’m aware no one wanted to help the soviets, no one had to but to say oh they joined the devil to lead the revolt from behind the front lines is absurd. You don’t get points for not being able to reign in your bullshit long enough for people to give a shit about you and yeah that applies just as well today as it did then.
I said internal for a reason. The archives, what’s left of them, are far more open than they used to be. People don’t write propaganda in their internal documentation because it isn’t meant for public eyes. They have no reason to lie to themselves. Please read this peer reviewed academic text regarding our specific discussion. The author is an expert in soviet military history and the great patriotic war in general. I assure you it is interesting and worth reading. I assumed you have not read because your opinion is no longer accepted by modern historiography. This is not something that is seriously debated anymore.
People write fraudulent internal documents all the time, your stance is predicated on soviets who were known to have bullshit government documents somehow have accurate documents in this case.
Sure people don’t lie to themselves, Trump is the best president ever I guess… Right? Or are we gonna back off that?
Ed: that appears to be a paid link btw.
if you have read a United States document then it was not internal. you and I both have no fucking idea what internal US documents look like right now. If you have seen a document claiming that trump is the best president ever and the economy is great then it is because that by definition was not an internal document. besides, my argument pales in comparison to the professor and prolific writer I linked. Please read the modern historical discussion regarding this topic. If you want more resources I would be happy to link them. I am otherwise disengaging as you seem more interested in defending an ideological position than engaging with history.
edit: yes internal documents are still subject to bias and I am not suggesting otherwise. The idea that they are subject to the sort of extreme bias you are suggesting however is very very rarely true and easy to see through when that is the case once compared with other historical evidence.
We don’t need to know more we know at the time there were documents created that were working or in part lies and untruths.
Very rarely except in the case of fascism who’s premise is in large part based on the ability to lie and lie and lie until people believe it.