Let’s hear them.
I can’t stand ‘Truly, Madly, Deeply’ by Savage Garden. It’s the song I do shitty renditions of to mock other songs
Runner up: ‘Arms Wide Open’ - Creed
Let’s hear them.
I can’t stand ‘Truly, Madly, Deeply’ by Savage Garden. It’s the song I do shitty renditions of to mock other songs
Runner up: ‘Arms Wide Open’ - Creed
Johnny Cash’s cover of Hurt sounds like shit. I thought people were joking about liking his warbly-ass voice doing a nearly monotone rendition of an originally emotional song.
You’d hate it if it was anyone but Johnny Cash. Don’t lie.
It’s so fucking good, and it’s made better because it’s Johnny Cash, he’s lived a life that he can sing that song with true feeling.
Is it good, though? Musically? If it weren’t Johnny Cash, would you listen to it a second time?
Lol maybe he could but he sure as hell didn’t in the studio. He’s more mumbling than singing. It sounds bored and emotionless.
Imo he does, he sings it as a weary old man.
Trent Razor loved Cash’s version so much he made the music video for it for free.
He just sounds like an old man.
And that second sentence is not true
Get the fuck out of my office.
The original is worse
I guess if you like listening to boring instrumentation and shitty vocals
People like guns and roses, lol.
I was gonna comment “Further evidence that something doesn’t have to be ‘good’ to be liked” but…I can’t think of a single guns and roses song so I’m hesitant to dunk on them lol
I’ll agree it isn’t his best recording, but I also don’t think that is the point. The emotional resonance of the song is the context around it. It is one of the last things he recorded, and he sounds old and tired and at the brink of death. It sounds like a reflection on his life. The music video really helps drive that home. To me, the song and the video are one piece of media and if you only listen to the song without watching the video, then you are only getting half of the experience.
The original is about struggling with addiction actively, but when he sings it, it sounds like someone singing about the regrets of their addiction, which is important for Johnny since he struggled with addiction to many substances over the course of his life.
There is also a parallel in tragedies. Trent was living in the house where Sharon Tate was murdered. A huge part of the song was him emotionally processing the gruesome acts that he now has a personal connection to. Johnny’s version dropped right after the 9/11 attacks and the same words that Trent wrote to process the tragedy seemed to really reasonable with Americans at the time. If you are below a certain age, I’m not sure exactly what to compare it to. Maybe “This is America” by Childish Gambino, but honestly, the difference in emotional impact and scale of the target audience doesn’t even really come close.
It kind of seems like you agree with me on just about every point:
And the music video is just a highlight reel of his amazing and successful life.
Your number 3 is a bit disingenuous. There’s not many people that could pull off that song even if they’re better singers on a technical level.
How is it disingenuous? The point is that if a lesser-known artist covered it this badly, no one would care about it.
People like the story around it and confuse that with the quality of the song.
I guarantee if you were out somewhere, in a world without Cash’s version and a random feeble old man played it just like cash did it would give you chills.
I’d enjoy it as a novelty but I doubt I’d get chills.
Regardless, that old man’s version wouldn’t be regarded as some incredible piece of art
Lots of people including the author of the song strongly disagree with you.
What was he gonna do, talk shit about Johnny Cash?
Finally someone who seems to share my hatred for that song
I understand why the original isn’t for everyone but it’s so dynamic, you really feel Trent Reznor going through the emotions as the song progresses.
People say that the cover is especially emotional but Johnny Cash doesn’t even sound sad, he sounds fuckin bored.
I have problems with depression and substance abuse and am old and his resignation hits harder than when it comes from someone who still cares.
I think people only praise that cover because he died shortly after and it brought it to more people’s attention. They’re always like, omg it’s a dying man singing about his regrets! Omg so amazing! But no, he sounds like shit and I say that as someone who was raised on Johnny Cash songs. Trent’s original is way more powerful. Especially if you’ve ever seen it live.
I think that’s it, too. The morbidity of the song plus his death.
I was also a fan of his going into it and even liked him on the “duet” version of I See A Darkness. I thought Hurt was a joke at first.
Nah, it’s gotta be someone old who doesn’t give a fuck. Doesn’t need to be Cash.
He sounds AWFUL. Terrible vocals, boring instrumentation, and a self aggrandizing music video to go along with it.
Cash’s rendition was weak; he was on fucking death’s door when he did it.
But what Cash brought to it was an actual pain. His health was failing; his wife was just about to die. They ended up shooting the video in his derelict museum because he was in too poor health to travel even locally.
Audio-wise, it’s crap, but emotionally, it’s about as powerful as a song could be.
So you agree.
yeah, mostly, it wouln’t have to be cash for me to like it, but it doesn’t stand on it’s own for it’d audio quality.