You uh, don’t play many team games do you? Where there’s different roles that achieve different results that overall contribute to the entirety of the effort?
I have a feeling you’re trying to hint at lend lease but that didn’t start arriving at scale until after the tide had turned on the eastern front. Even American historians of the Eastern Front like David Glantz, argue that without lend lease the USSR still defeats Germany, but that it would have simply taken longer.
If you do 80% of the work for a group project saying you did it almost single-handedly remains entirely fair even if the deadline was brought up with help from others in my opinion.
I would argue that the Soviets were overwhelmingly responsible for the allies winning the war. However, I don’t think it wouldn’t be historically accurate to underplay the importance of the lend and lease program.
I think they would have probably still won without lend and lease, mainly because the Nazi decided to stop at Stalingrad. However it would have gone on much longer and killed so many more civilians than it already did. Plus they would have lacked the mobility for a counter offensive that prevented the Nazi from making a organized retreat.
The vast majority of lend and lease supplies arrived in 43 and 44, so I don’t think it would be completely accurate to say the tide had already turned at that particular point. Stalin, Khrushchev, and Marshal Zhukov all claimed that lend and lease was vital to winning the war.
You should look into what percentage of those supplies were food goods to stop the civilian population from starving and collapsing into cannibalism… Fun fact Russia 's bread basket is on the Western side of Russia.
More like American food. The Materiel didn’t arrive until later after the tide had turned, but @[email protected] is somewhat correct about many more civilians would have died without aid, but it isn’t an increase in mobility (that was mostly T-34s and Soviet vehicles) but since Ukraine and South Western Russia was the major breadbasket, the food aid was really critical to keeping more people alive. That was the critical aid that Stalin, Zhukov, etc. were actually crediting along with it mostly being diplomatic to try to maintain good relations after the end of the war.
It is a secondary source, but I believe the Historian guesting on this episode does cite other sources.
Edit: forgot that there was another episode with the same historian disputing myths about WW2 and lend-lease after a Nazi apologist gave disinformation on Tucker Carlson’s program
but it isn’t an increase in mobility (that was mostly T-34s and Soviet vehicles)
I was more referring to the logistical support that allowed army movements, not the actual mobile weapons. In 1943 and 44 around 300k Studebaker, jeeps, and thousands of tons of Petro chemical products were shipped to Russia along with much needed railway equipment and components, including over 1000 locomotives by 1934.
One of the most important logistical support items that isn’t talked about enough is communications. The US shipped tens of thousands of radios and transmitting equipment to Russia that allowed rapid coordination and movement for both the fighting force and supply line. Of course tons of food was shipped, but it’s not exactly helpful to have millions of tons of food without the logistical capability to transport and distribute it.
Arguably Hitler was responsible for losing the war after opening a second front after believing in his armies innate superiority rather than a fair measure of luck in the initial European campaign.
Aside from lend-lease there was also the strategic bombing of the Nazi manufacturing base, the navel blockade, the intelligence gathering and eventually the second front in the form of the largest amphibious assault in history.
To ignore those and say the Soviets could have won the war by themselves is certainly a take but I don’t think the counterfactual would have held up. Indeed fearing that is one of the reasons they initially allied with Hitler over Poland even if they realised they would eventually have to fight the Nazis later.
At no point did the USSR ally with the Nazis, because fascism and communism are enemies at the most fundamental level. Fascism is the capitalist class it its most ruthless, while communism is anti-capitalist to its core.
If the USSR was allied with the Nazis, what does that say about the states that signed non-aggression pacts before it did? For many of them, they were treaties of desperation, not allyship.
The USSR only signed that after its offer of a million Soviet troops to help fight the Nazis was rejected by the UK and France. It only signed it after all other options had been exhausted. They signed it in the hopes of stalling Germany’s inevitable invasion, giving them time to build up their military strength. And it worked.
Germany invaded Poland, and the Polish government collapsed. In response, the USSR went into Poland to keep Germany from occupying all of Poland, which would have broken the agreement regarding “spheres of influence.” And in fact Germany did break that agreement. Once Germany entered Poland, all of Poland would have been occupied by the Nazis if the USSR had done nothing, and that would have put the German forces right on the USSR’s border.
If you didn’t feel the need to add obvious falsehoods I’d almost be inclined to concede the point slightly that almost singlehandedly is hyperbolic (but far less than the average westerner would think given many think the US was the most important antiNazi power). If non aggression pacts and enforcement of redlines against the Nazis (which was more than the appeasement model of the time managed) count as allying that doesn’t bode well for any of the rest of the Allies given the Soviets were the last major power to sign a non aggression pact.
Edit: Also the Molotov-Ribbentrop was signed not out of fear of fighting Germany alone but to build up production enough to deal with the very real possibility of the rest of Europe allying with Hitler given there constant shooting down of every Soviet attempt to form an Anti-Nazi alliance. For example Poland themselves preferring to invade Czechoslovakia rather than allow the red army passage to fight Hitler.
For example Poland themselves preferring to invade Czechoslovakia rather than allow the red army passage to fight Hitler.
Did they? I know virtually nothing about the carving up of Czechoslovakia. NATOpedia claims that Poland only grabbed a small spit of already-contested territory.
Sequence of events following the Munich Agreement:
The Sudetenland became part of Germany in accordance with the Munich Agreement (October 1938).
Poland annexes Trans-Olza, an area with a Polish plurality, over which the two countries had fought a war in 1919 (October 1938).
Border areas (southern third of Slovakia and southern Carpathian Ruthenia) with Hungarian minorities became part of Hungary in accordance with the First Vienna Award (November 1938).
On 15 March 1939, during the German invasion of the remaining Czech territories, Hungary annexes the remainder of Carpathian Ruthenia (which had been autonomous since October 1938).
Germany establishes the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia with a puppet government, on 16 March 1939.
On 14 March 1939, a pro-Hitler Catholic-fascist government declares the Slovak Republic, as an Axis client state.
So the invasion of Poland, various annexations and agreement to split countries into spheres of influence where just figments of our collective imagination?
It’s interesting that Western discourse of the history of WW2 is full of analysis of the various mistakes and follies of apeasment as a strategy but for some the USSR never did anything wrong. Even now there are historians critical of Yalta although it’s understandable in a world weary of war that the main impetus at the time was to freeze the status quo.
So the invasion of Poland, various annexations and agreement to split countries into spheres of influence where just figments of our collective imagination?
The “invasion” of Poland consisted of stationing troops in what had become polish occupied (during the interwar period) Belarus, Ukraine, and Lithuania after the polish government fell and enforcing a redline against the Nazis. Of course you would obviously have preferred no such redline was enforced and the Nazis were free to continue advancing eastward./s
I have plenty of criticisms of the Soviets you simply very clearly lack even a basic understanding of the context history and political and economic theory to even begin to have a discussion on the level required to really get into that so we’re left with this dynamic of you making claims and others having to point out they’re not exactly aligned with reality.
“If we see that Germany is winning we ought to help Russia and if Russia is winning we ought to help Germany, and that way let them kill as many as possible, although I don’t want to see Hitler victorious under any circumstances.”
Harry S. Truman
Churchill […] added some words of praise: “I have always said that if Britain were defeated in a war I hoped [that] we should find a Hitler to lead us back to our rightful position among nations.” The world would now rejoice, Churchill said, to see a mellowed Hitler of peace and tolerance. “Let this great man search his own heart and conscience before he accuses any one of being a warmonger.”
At Leghorn, Lady Chamberlain was photographed with the Duce, wearing the Fascist insignia; and Winston Churchill declared on January 20, 1927, that he “could not help being charmed by Mussolini’s gentle and simple bearing”: “if I had been an Italian I am sure that I would have been whole‐heartedly with you. […] Your movement has rendered a service to the whole world […] provided the necessary antidote to the Russian poison.” He, too, would don a blackshirt if he were an Italian.³
You uh, don’t play many team games do you? Where there’s different roles that achieve different results that overall contribute to the entirety of the effort?
I have a feeling you’re trying to hint at lend lease but that didn’t start arriving at scale until after the tide had turned on the eastern front. Even American historians of the Eastern Front like David Glantz, argue that without lend lease the USSR still defeats Germany, but that it would have simply taken longer.
If you do 80% of the work for a group project saying you did it almost single-handedly remains entirely fair even if the deadline was brought up with help from others in my opinion.
I would argue that the Soviets were overwhelmingly responsible for the allies winning the war. However, I don’t think it wouldn’t be historically accurate to underplay the importance of the lend and lease program.
I think they would have probably still won without lend and lease, mainly because the Nazi decided to stop at Stalingrad. However it would have gone on much longer and killed so many more civilians than it already did. Plus they would have lacked the mobility for a counter offensive that prevented the Nazi from making a organized retreat.
The vast majority of lend and lease supplies arrived in 43 and 44, so I don’t think it would be completely accurate to say the tide had already turned at that particular point. Stalin, Khrushchev, and Marshal Zhukov all claimed that lend and lease was vital to winning the war.
You should look into what percentage of those supplies were food goods to stop the civilian population from starving and collapsing into cannibalism… Fun fact Russia 's bread basket is on the Western side of Russia.
American guns, British intelligence, Russian lives, as the saying goes.
Yeah but where do they say that primarily?
More like American food. The Materiel didn’t arrive until later after the tide had turned, but @[email protected] is somewhat correct about many more civilians would have died without aid, but it isn’t an increase in mobility (that was mostly T-34s and Soviet vehicles) but since Ukraine and South Western Russia was the major breadbasket, the food aid was really critical to keeping more people alive. That was the critical aid that Stalin, Zhukov, etc. were actually crediting along with it mostly being diplomatic to try to maintain good relations after the end of the war.
It is a secondary source, but I believe the Historian guesting on this episode does cite other sources.
Radio War Nerd, Ep. 592 - Operation Barbarossa pt 8: The Soviet Union in War Time
Edit: forgot that there was another episode with the same historian disputing myths about WW2 and lend-lease after a Nazi apologist gave disinformation on Tucker Carlson’s program
Radio War Nerd EP 470 — Operation Bagration, Pt. 4: WWII Myths, feat. Annibale
Annibale returns to discuss WW2 myths and distortions, from the revisionist-right ramblings of Darryl Cooper about the war’s origins, to the controversy over Lend-Lease’s role in the Red Army’s successes up to Operation Bagration.
I was more referring to the logistical support that allowed army movements, not the actual mobile weapons. In 1943 and 44 around 300k Studebaker, jeeps, and thousands of tons of Petro chemical products were shipped to Russia along with much needed railway equipment and components, including over 1000 locomotives by 1934.
One of the most important logistical support items that isn’t talked about enough is communications. The US shipped tens of thousands of radios and transmitting equipment to Russia that allowed rapid coordination and movement for both the fighting force and supply line. Of course tons of food was shipped, but it’s not exactly helpful to have millions of tons of food without the logistical capability to transport and distribute it.
Arguably Hitler was responsible for losing the war after opening a second front after believing in his armies innate superiority rather than a fair measure of luck in the initial European campaign.
happens when all of western Europe co-operates and make pacts with you in hopes of crushing the USSR
Aside from lend-lease there was also the strategic bombing of the Nazi manufacturing base, the navel blockade, the intelligence gathering and eventually the second front in the form of the largest amphibious assault in history.
To ignore those and say the Soviets could have won the war by themselves is certainly a take but I don’t think the counterfactual would have held up. Indeed fearing that is one of the reasons they initially allied with Hitler over Poland even if they realised they would eventually have to fight the Nazis later.
At no point did the USSR ally with the Nazis, because fascism and communism are enemies at the most fundamental level. Fascism is the capitalist class it its most ruthless, while communism is anti-capitalist to its core.
If the USSR was allied with the Nazis, what does that say about the states that signed non-aggression pacts before it did? For many of them, they were treaties of desperation, not allyship.
The USSR only signed that after its offer of a million Soviet troops to help fight the Nazis was rejected by the UK and France. It only signed it after all other options had been exhausted. They signed it in the hopes of stalling Germany’s inevitable invasion, giving them time to build up their military strength. And it worked.
Germany invaded Poland, and the Polish government collapsed. In response, the USSR went into Poland to keep Germany from occupying all of Poland, which would have broken the agreement regarding “spheres of influence.” And in fact Germany did break that agreement. Once Germany entered Poland, all of Poland would have been occupied by the Nazis if the USSR had done nothing, and that would have put the German forces right on the USSR’s border.
If you didn’t feel the need to add obvious falsehoods I’d almost be inclined to concede the point slightly that almost singlehandedly is hyperbolic (but far less than the average westerner would think given many think the US was the most important antiNazi power). If non aggression pacts and enforcement of redlines against the Nazis (which was more than the appeasement model of the time managed) count as allying that doesn’t bode well for any of the rest of the Allies given the Soviets were the last major power to sign a non aggression pact.
Edit: Also the Molotov-Ribbentrop was signed not out of fear of fighting Germany alone but to build up production enough to deal with the very real possibility of the rest of Europe allying with Hitler given there constant shooting down of every Soviet attempt to form an Anti-Nazi alliance. For example Poland themselves preferring to invade Czechoslovakia rather than allow the red army passage to fight Hitler.
Did they? I know virtually nothing about the carving up of Czechoslovakia. NATOpedia claims that Poland only grabbed a small spit of already-contested territory.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Munich_Agreement
So the invasion of Poland, various annexations and agreement to split countries into spheres of influence where just figments of our collective imagination?
It’s interesting that Western discourse of the history of WW2 is full of analysis of the various mistakes and follies of apeasment as a strategy but for some the USSR never did anything wrong. Even now there are historians critical of Yalta although it’s understandable in a world weary of war that the main impetus at the time was to freeze the status quo.
Name at least 5 Polish cities that the USSR supposedly invaded in 1939.
The “invasion” of Poland consisted of stationing troops in what had become polish occupied (during the interwar period) Belarus, Ukraine, and Lithuania after the polish government fell and enforcing a redline against the Nazis. Of course you would obviously have preferred no such redline was enforced and the Nazis were free to continue advancing eastward./s
I have plenty of criticisms of the Soviets you simply very clearly lack even a basic understanding of the context history and political and economic theory to even begin to have a discussion on the level required to really get into that so we’re left with this dynamic of you making claims and others having to point out they’re not exactly aligned with reality.
Harry S. Truman
Winston Churchill
Thanks to @[email protected] for the stuff on Churchill!
https://lemmygrad.ml/post/2848151
https://lemmy.ml/post/55516121/29171523