At this stage, loving and pretending the Soviet Union is successful and still functional is necrophilia.

  • NOT_RICK
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    7 hours ago

    Thanks for the answer. I think Stalin’s purges were at a minimum partially self serving, for example what threat to the revolution did Trotsky pose halfway around the world, but I will concede that at least some of it likely well intentioned.

    I do think it’s notable that you mention party elites accumulating wealth in the USSR, are we not seeing the same kinds of wealth discrepancies growing in China? I do agree that self criticism and introspection is essential to any form of governance

    • freagle@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      6 hours ago

      are we not seeing the same kinds of wealth discrepancies growing in China?

      Yes and no. Most of the wealth accumulation is from private citizens who are not party members and most of that wealth accumulation is through capitalist flows of profit not state appropriation through positional authority.

      But also, as much as the Western media has been crowing about Xi purging the military and claiming that it’s about personal fealty, the entire party appartus is communicating in terms of removing the influence of money and special interest groups from political and military positions of power and influence.

      Which goes back to that idea of having institutionalized self-criticism.

      So again, it remains to be seen if China has figured out a way to use capitalism’s resource allocation power without allowing the profit motive to fundamentally steer the direction of the state. It also remains to be seen if any other communist revolution can do the same thing, achieve the same goal with different means, or go a totally different direction.