Essentially you’re saying the only true form of socialism is the form that is powerless and not in control.
Never said that, but you did which only adds to what I am saying. The jig is up, it is just just more murderers with a slightly better sounding rhetoric.
term for it, and that term is “Western Marxism”. It
Weak scapegoating pretending to be informed. This kind of nonsense is why it is hard for you to be taken seriously.
". It is a position that will never liberate anyone an
Ah yes another my “ideology will rise from the ashes” authoritarian bootlicker disguised as a human rights defender. Such a common trope here.
That’s a strong claim using undefined terms.
Says the guy putting people on pedestals, give me a break.
Stalin is celebrated
Fucking disgusting as I already mentioned.
Both Clinton and Obama presided over the greatest enemy of humanity for 8 years.
Oh please, they did not order massive campaigns of death and destruction. Obama’s drone campaign killed a fraction of the people Stalin did on a bad day. I absolutely hated Obama carrying on the drone campaign, but that is entirely different than ordering the secret police to kill upwards of a thousand citizens a day. Inability to compare the magnitude of leaders personal decisions is very telling.
Clinton was the first person in modern history to launch do a war for “humanitarian” reasons.
Fashioning Clinton as a war monger has to be one of the silliest examples of bad propaganda I have ever seen. He was a neofascist womanizer. If you are going to hate the guy, at least have real non shitty Russian propaganda reasons.
He also deported over 3M people, significantly more than Trump,
I know, it makes Trump supporters cry because Obama and Biden already legally deported all the problem leaving poor Trump with only legal immigrants to deport.
Stalin presided over a period of time when US and English businessmen were
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
Words have meaning. I am not murderous.
Going to have to respectfully call bullshit here.
Says the person who thinks collective punishment by the global hegemon is “indirect action” and therefore morally superior literally anything a communist party has done.
I never said that. What a weak attempt to paint me into a corner. Why is criticizing the dysfunctionalism that is communism a ringing endorsement of the current world paradigm of Neofascist Leverage Capitalists. No, you just act like a hopeless campist who can’t see that it is no longer even about nations anymore.
You are on the verge of literally speaking without meaning.
“Scapegoating” is singling out a person or group and assigning blame to them. That’s not what’s happening here. I’m critiquing your position and assigning the label of Western Marxism which is critiqued in the socialist discourse. From the summary of critique:
J. G. Merquior argues that the movement’s defining flaw was its embrace of Kulturkritik, which led it to reject historical analysis in favor of sweeping, often romantic, indictments of modern civilization. In his view, this resulted in a “theoreticism” that produced little of value for sociological or historical understanding.
That’s the criticism I am levying at you. There’s no scapegoating here. That’s not what that word means.
Ah yes another my “ideology will rise from the ashes” authoritarian bootlicker disguised as a human rights defender
Again, another misunderstanding so complete it feels like you’re arguing with a ghost in your head. It’s so bad, I have to take it in 3 parts:
my “ideology will rise from the ashes”
My criticism of Western Marxism as impotent is not in any way, shape, or form me saying “my ideology will rise from the ashes” because I don’t think my ideology is in ashes. I think Marxism-Leninism as an ideology is still alive and well in Cuba, China, Vietnam, and Laos at the very least. It’s far from dead.
authoritarian
I would challenge you to define this word in any way that doesn’t implicate basically every state that has ever existed. It’s a meaningless term, and if you were actually engaged in socialist discourse (and I don’t mean with MLs, I just mean generally) you would know that “authoritarian” is often critiqued as a word without any actual meaning or utility. Again, the US is the most egregious abuser of authority in the world per capita by a large margin. Wars are exercises in authority. Revolutions are exercises in authority. This critique is meaningless.
disguised as a human rights defender
The concept of human rights is a liberal construct. Marxism views rights as legal fictions that emerge as part of the superstructure. I’m not pretending to be a defender of human rights. I am stating plainly that liberalism is a political philosophy of subjugation and that communism is a political philosophy of liberation. As a political philosophy of liberation it seeks to understand the root cause of subjugation and it has arrived at the conclusion that class society is the root cause of subjugation, and therefore abolition of classes is the path to liberation. It has also concluded that the only way to abolish classes is to abolish the owning class, and the only way to do that is through repression of the owning class and the reactionaries who would re-establish it. That necessarily involves violating human rights. We’re clear eyed about that. The path to universal liberation is on the other side of repressing the owning class. That’s the political theory, that’s the analysis, that’s the prescription. You can disagree with that. That’s OK. But that’s not a form of Marxism and you’re lying to yourself if you think it is.
Says the guy putting people on pedestals
You never defined the term. So as it stands you have uttered words without meaning and declined the opportunity to clarify yourself.
Stalin is celebrated
Fucking disgusting as I already mentioned.
Yeah, I mean at this point, it’s like I’m talking to an LLM that was trained to regurgitate randomized moral outrage. You think it’s disgusting to celebrate the leader of the military that defeated the Third Reich, took Berlin, and did so at great national cost. As the saying goes “We liberated Europe from fascism, but they will never forgive us for it”.
Inability to compare the magnitude of leaders personal decisions is very telling.
And inability to incorporate any of what I said into your understanding of my position is also very telling. As I have already stated, Stalin did a lot of terrible things. But as I also stated, comparing the leader of a country that was the target of the combined industrial power of Western Europe, that was invaded multiple times, including by the US, and ultimately had to fight the vast majority of Nazi forces to a president of a country that has literally never had anyone attack at their borders is not a valid basis for comparison. Every bomb dropped by an American president was a bomb of choice, while Stalin was specifically operating with the existential threat of the Germans on meth enslaving the Slavs for centuries. They’re not comparable. And again, even while they’re not comparable, Stalin still did horrible things. And even still, while Stalin did horrible things, he did not just go on war adventures bombing people on the other side of the planet to dominate them and he did not starve children, pregnant women, and the elderly in over a dozen countries for the crime of national self-determination.
Obama and Biden already legally deported all the problem
Oh, wow. So you actually think that the combined 8M people deported by Obama and Biden were all just violent criminals. 8M violent criminals? Really? OK then. And you call me an authoritarian bootlicker? This is what Blue MAGA looks like.
That’s because objectively they aren’t symmetrical situations. Stalin presided over a period of time when US and English businessmen were funding the Third Reich as they developed the world’s most advanced war machine to invade and subjugate all of Russia and the Caucuses.
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
I mean, that just says it all, doesn’t it? I’m literally talking about how the Nazis, led by Hitler, were funded and what their goals were and how the target of their invasion sought to defend themselves and their neighbors from Hitler and the Nazis, and you can’t tell the difference between that and a Nazi defending Hitler. I mean, fair enough! If that’s how you process information, well, I guess that’s all there is to it. You can’t tell the difference between the violence of the master against the slave or the violence of the slave against the master. Both are wrong to you. And that’s why virtue ethics is, ironically, morally bankrupt.
Words have meaning. I am not murderous.
Going to have to respectfully call bullshit here.
On which statement? I bet I can guess which one!
Why is criticizing the dysfunctionalism that is communism a ringing endorsement of the current world paradigm of Neofascist Leverage Capitalists
Because you literally said:
I greatly dislike Neofascism, but objectively there is no comparison between their direct actions and loss of life.
You are making a claim that there is an objective moral superiority of Neofascism over all historical movements for communism. But then again, I’m coming to realize that you think it’s bullshit that words have meaning, so I guess I can’t expect you to understand even your words and their implications because you’re just spitting vibes and don’t have any idea that there’s actually any analysis or critique to be done by anyone, least of all you. All that’s important is that you vehemently distance yourself from anything that might morally taint you.
No, you just act like a hopeless campist who can’t see that it is no longer even about nations anymore.
Very funny on both counts. It’s not about nations anymore, that’s why the world imperial hegemon hates it when nations nationalize their national resources and will do everything in their power to stop nations from nationalizing their national resources via nationalist movements. Because it’s not about nations anymore.
As for the claim of campism, I think that’s funny as well. It’s a thought terminating cliche. Try to define the camps that you think I see and how I’m choosing a specific camp and arguing against other camps. I’m sorry. That’s unfair of me to ask. You couldn’t do that. You don’t have any idea what you’re saying. You don’t know what campism means, the history of the term, what the historical camps were, how they related to each other. To you, words are dirt to throw at your opponent, not things with meaning and history.
I have an analysis. I have argued for that analysis. I have attempted to answer your criticism. And what you have given me back is moralizing. You have axiomatically defined what is “good” and what is “bad” and you have stripped all other context to ensure that you can apply your labels in a way that makes you the good guy. Don’t believe me? Here’s what someone like you would say:
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
Scapegoating" is singling out a person or group and assigning blame to them.
You are indeed labeling me and blaming me for an ideology I do not have. Perhaps this is an ESL thing for you. I am not sure.
Western Marxism which is critiqued in the socialist discourse
Well there is your problem, this is not my criticism at all.
I would challenge you to define this word
Neoauthoritarianism is the evolution of authoritarianism. It is seen throughout Asia and I would argue in the US now as well. I am well aware of ML propaganda in regards to this and I soundly reject it.
My criticism of Western Marxism
Hey I get it, you are willing to let people to die for your revolution. You don’t have to pretend about your warped views in regards to a powerful socialist/communist nation. I already know where you are coming from.
You never defined the term
Says the guy lamenting how good murderous dictators were. Just experiments after all.
Yeah, I mean at this point, it’s like I’m talking to an LLM that was trained to regurgitate randomized moral outrage
You have to be extra psychotic to deny what he did.
And inability to incorporate any of what I said into your understanding of my position is also very telling.
You have never stated your position, only your criticism of a position I don’t have.
Both are wrong to you. And
Please, people who minimize what either of the monsters did are certainly wrong. They disgust me and people who defend them do as well. I hope that you are just offering an impartial historical perspective rather than a ham fisted attempt at defense.
Never said that, but you did which only adds to what I am saying. The jig is up, it is just just more murderers with a slightly better sounding rhetoric.
Weak scapegoating pretending to be informed. This kind of nonsense is why it is hard for you to be taken seriously.
Ah yes another my “ideology will rise from the ashes” authoritarian bootlicker disguised as a human rights defender. Such a common trope here.
Says the guy putting people on pedestals, give me a break.
Fucking disgusting as I already mentioned.
Oh please, they did not order massive campaigns of death and destruction. Obama’s drone campaign killed a fraction of the people Stalin did on a bad day. I absolutely hated Obama carrying on the drone campaign, but that is entirely different than ordering the secret police to kill upwards of a thousand citizens a day. Inability to compare the magnitude of leaders personal decisions is very telling.
Fashioning Clinton as a war monger has to be one of the silliest examples of bad propaganda I have ever seen. He was a neofascist womanizer. If you are going to hate the guy, at least have real non shitty Russian propaganda reasons.
I know, it makes Trump supporters cry because Obama and Biden already legally deported all the problem leaving poor Trump with only legal immigrants to deport.
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
Going to have to respectfully call bullshit here.
I never said that. What a weak attempt to paint me into a corner. Why is criticizing the dysfunctionalism that is communism a ringing endorsement of the current world paradigm of Neofascist Leverage Capitalists. No, you just act like a hopeless campist who can’t see that it is no longer even about nations anymore.
You are on the verge of literally speaking without meaning.
“Scapegoating” is singling out a person or group and assigning blame to them. That’s not what’s happening here. I’m critiquing your position and assigning the label of Western Marxism which is critiqued in the socialist discourse. From the summary of critique:
That’s the criticism I am levying at you. There’s no scapegoating here. That’s not what that word means.
Again, another misunderstanding so complete it feels like you’re arguing with a ghost in your head. It’s so bad, I have to take it in 3 parts:
My criticism of Western Marxism as impotent is not in any way, shape, or form me saying “my ideology will rise from the ashes” because I don’t think my ideology is in ashes. I think Marxism-Leninism as an ideology is still alive and well in Cuba, China, Vietnam, and Laos at the very least. It’s far from dead.
I would challenge you to define this word in any way that doesn’t implicate basically every state that has ever existed. It’s a meaningless term, and if you were actually engaged in socialist discourse (and I don’t mean with MLs, I just mean generally) you would know that “authoritarian” is often critiqued as a word without any actual meaning or utility. Again, the US is the most egregious abuser of authority in the world per capita by a large margin. Wars are exercises in authority. Revolutions are exercises in authority. This critique is meaningless.
The concept of human rights is a liberal construct. Marxism views rights as legal fictions that emerge as part of the superstructure. I’m not pretending to be a defender of human rights. I am stating plainly that liberalism is a political philosophy of subjugation and that communism is a political philosophy of liberation. As a political philosophy of liberation it seeks to understand the root cause of subjugation and it has arrived at the conclusion that class society is the root cause of subjugation, and therefore abolition of classes is the path to liberation. It has also concluded that the only way to abolish classes is to abolish the owning class, and the only way to do that is through repression of the owning class and the reactionaries who would re-establish it. That necessarily involves violating human rights. We’re clear eyed about that. The path to universal liberation is on the other side of repressing the owning class. That’s the political theory, that’s the analysis, that’s the prescription. You can disagree with that. That’s OK. But that’s not a form of Marxism and you’re lying to yourself if you think it is.
You never defined the term. So as it stands you have uttered words without meaning and declined the opportunity to clarify yourself.
Yeah, I mean at this point, it’s like I’m talking to an LLM that was trained to regurgitate randomized moral outrage. You think it’s disgusting to celebrate the leader of the military that defeated the Third Reich, took Berlin, and did so at great national cost. As the saying goes “We liberated Europe from fascism, but they will never forgive us for it”.
And inability to incorporate any of what I said into your understanding of my position is also very telling. As I have already stated, Stalin did a lot of terrible things. But as I also stated, comparing the leader of a country that was the target of the combined industrial power of Western Europe, that was invaded multiple times, including by the US, and ultimately had to fight the vast majority of Nazi forces to a president of a country that has literally never had anyone attack at their borders is not a valid basis for comparison. Every bomb dropped by an American president was a bomb of choice, while Stalin was specifically operating with the existential threat of the Germans on meth enslaving the Slavs for centuries. They’re not comparable. And again, even while they’re not comparable, Stalin still did horrible things. And even still, while Stalin did horrible things, he did not just go on war adventures bombing people on the other side of the planet to dominate them and he did not starve children, pregnant women, and the elderly in over a dozen countries for the crime of national self-determination.
Oh, wow. So you actually think that the combined 8M people deported by Obama and Biden were all just violent criminals. 8M violent criminals? Really? OK then. And you call me an authoritarian bootlicker? This is what Blue MAGA looks like.
I mean, that just says it all, doesn’t it? I’m literally talking about how the Nazis, led by Hitler, were funded and what their goals were and how the target of their invasion sought to defend themselves and their neighbors from Hitler and the Nazis, and you can’t tell the difference between that and a Nazi defending Hitler. I mean, fair enough! If that’s how you process information, well, I guess that’s all there is to it. You can’t tell the difference between the violence of the master against the slave or the violence of the slave against the master. Both are wrong to you. And that’s why virtue ethics is, ironically, morally bankrupt.
On which statement? I bet I can guess which one!
Because you literally said:
You are making a claim that there is an objective moral superiority of Neofascism over all historical movements for communism. But then again, I’m coming to realize that you think it’s bullshit that words have meaning, so I guess I can’t expect you to understand even your words and their implications because you’re just spitting vibes and don’t have any idea that there’s actually any analysis or critique to be done by anyone, least of all you. All that’s important is that you vehemently distance yourself from anything that might morally taint you.
Very funny on both counts. It’s not about nations anymore, that’s why the world imperial hegemon hates it when nations nationalize their national resources and will do everything in their power to stop nations from nationalizing their national resources via nationalist movements. Because it’s not about nations anymore.
As for the claim of campism, I think that’s funny as well. It’s a thought terminating cliche. Try to define the camps that you think I see and how I’m choosing a specific camp and arguing against other camps. I’m sorry. That’s unfair of me to ask. You couldn’t do that. You don’t have any idea what you’re saying. You don’t know what campism means, the history of the term, what the historical camps were, how they related to each other. To you, words are dirt to throw at your opponent, not things with meaning and history.
I have an analysis. I have argued for that analysis. I have attempted to answer your criticism. And what you have given me back is moralizing. You have axiomatically defined what is “good” and what is “bad” and you have stripped all other context to ensure that you can apply your labels in a way that makes you the good guy. Don’t believe me? Here’s what someone like you would say:
I mean. That really does say it all, doesn’t it.
You are indeed labeling me and blaming me for an ideology I do not have. Perhaps this is an ESL thing for you. I am not sure.
Well there is your problem, this is not my criticism at all.
Neoauthoritarianism is the evolution of authoritarianism. It is seen throughout Asia and I would argue in the US now as well. I am well aware of ML propaganda in regards to this and I soundly reject it.
Hey I get it, you are willing to let people to die for your revolution. You don’t have to pretend about your warped views in regards to a powerful socialist/communist nation. I already know where you are coming from.
Says the guy lamenting how good murderous dictators were. Just experiments after all.
You have to be extra psychotic to deny what he did.
You have never stated your position, only your criticism of a position I don’t have.
Please, people who minimize what either of the monsters did are certainly wrong. They disgust me and people who defend them do as well. I hope that you are just offering an impartial historical perspective rather than a ham fisted attempt at defense.