• @penitentOne
    link
    English
    910 months ago

    To those of you who propose 100% renewables + storage. In cases with no access to hydro power. How much energy storage do you need? How does it scale with production/consumption? What about a system with 100TWh yearly production/consumption?

      • @penitentOne
        link
        English
        110 months ago

        Interesting product. Reading about it quickly it seems to have a problem with self discharge. But perhaps they have ironed out that problem. There is no shortage of promising battery news, but there seems to be a problem getting them to mass production. Hoping this one is different.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      -110 months ago

      EVs with VTG. Problem solved. More importantly, energy production (solar plus wind) and storage (batteries) are completely decentralized, which is a huge security improvement for the grid. It amazes me that a platform that is decentralized doesn’t beat the drum for the same for energy production and storage.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        310 months ago

        How do you generate energy during the winter? Are we going to run HVDC to the Sahara and connect them globally?

      • @currycourier
        link
        English
        210 months ago

        Is there any more in-depth analysis to show how many EVs would be needed to make this feasible, how this would work with time of day use of power from commutes vs generation from solar power, how long the grid could stay powered this way, impact on consumers range, etc? I think the concept seems simple at first but would it actually be resiliant relying on just EV batteries? A cloudy week could see everyone run out of power, for example.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          210 months ago

          A single Tesla powerwall has 13.5kwh of usable energy. An average Tesla car has between 70-100kwh of usable energy. The average American home uses about 30kwh/day (https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=97&t=3). There are about 141 million houses in the US. There are 275 million personal and commercial vehicles in the US. So there would be plenty of capacity once you replace a significant chunk of those vehicles with EV.

          Cloudy weeks don’t occur over large areas - if you look at solar or wind production over an entire county or state, for example, it varies very little (that’s also the advantage of using both sun and wind - when one is bad the other is typically good). So the solution to intermittency is mass adoption.

          • @penitentOne
            link
            English
            1
            edit-2
            10 months ago

            In regards to V2G. Tesla is not even supporting bi-directional charging at this point and it is just now starting to become a bit more common in newer models. It would be interesting to see more detailed example about this. You would also need to include the usage of industry and commercial which as far as I know together account for more than residential usage. How about availability in terms of SOC and being plugged in or not. I think this is a bit more difficult to solve than you are alluding to but I’m happy to be proved wrong.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              010 months ago

              This is a far easier problem and solution than building a nuclear reactor. And it’s utilizing something (EVs) that we need anyway so improved utilization of resources.

          • @MrFagtron9000
            link
            English
            010 months ago

            I live in a 1000 square foot two bedroom condo. When it gets below 20° f, which does a lot during the winter, I have to use the auxiliary heat on my heat pump unit.

            That’s 7.5 kW.

            So just to stay warm during the night, when solar stops working, I would need 3-5 Power Walls?

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              210 months ago

              Get a better heat pump that doesn’t need aux heat? I know Mitsu “hyper heat” minisplits advertise high efficiency to -10F.

              Powerwalls are overpriced for their capacity. Grid storage operators pay ~$150/kwh for batteries, then I’d guess about the same for charging/inverter electronics. I also see EV West sells 3.5kwh Samsung batteries to average consumers for $700 (I’m sure they’re charging a large markup as well).

              • @MrFagtron9000
                link
                English
                110 months ago

                Are you going to buy me a new heat pump?

                Also why doesn’t anyone make a hyper efficient central system? I’ve only seen those hyper efficient units as mini splits.

                Are you going to replace my 2016 Sonata I spent $13k on buying in 2018 with a $55k EV with car to grid for me?

                What happens if it’s dark and cold for multiple days? I just can’t drive because my car emptied out running my minisplits?

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  110 months ago

                  Lol. Was just offering suggestions you may have not known about. Off-grid isn’t practical for many people who aren’t willing make sacrifices just for the sake of it. Some people like the challenge and lifestyle. Renewable power plants are more efficient than residential. I think used Leafs can be pretty cheap, and even new EVs, solar panels (grid-tied), and more efficient appliances can save you money in the long run. Not sure if it makes sense to sell EV charge back to the grid (I guess it does if the price is right).

                  I’ve heard of some people on certain electricity plans overheat or overcool their house when electricity is cheap to save money (acting kinda like storage for when electricity is more expensive).

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              110 months ago

              Nice to meet you MrFagtron An EV would be a much better investment than powerwalls but it’s hard to be specific on a case by case basis. Hope that helps MrFagtron.

        • @datelmd5sum
          link
          English
          210 months ago

          Yeah at higher latitudes the energy consumption is highest when renewable production is lowest.

          • @droans
            link
            English
            1
            edit-2
            10 months ago

            Geothermal would work, but it is very expensive unless you have a large property or a decent sized pond.

            It would still require power from other sources, but would dramatically reduce demand.

            • @datelmd5sum
              link
              English
              19 months ago

              Geothermal was trialed and deemed unprofitable. Nuclear power has been serving our baseload needs for 50 years.