• XIIIesq
    link
    -5
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    There is a good reason.

    People can picture one ton in their heads, no one can picture one million individual grams.

    You can imagine a ton bag of sand, you can’t imagine one million individual grains of sand that weigh one gram each.

    The term “megagram” does make perfect sense, but it doesn’t fit well with the way the people experience the universe around them.

    It’s the exact same reason that weight is the only SI unit where the kilogram is the standard rather than the gram. You can imagine holding a kilo in your hands (about 2.2lb if you’re American) and you could easily tell the difference between 1 and two kilos, or 1 and 0.5 of a kilo, but if you hold a gram it feels like nothing, and you probably wouldn’t be able to sense a difference between 1 and two grams etc.

    Edit: didn’t think explaining that people like to describe the universe as they experience it rather than being pedants about measuring weights to the precise gram every time would be an unpopular opinion lol

    • @Shialac
      link
      41 year ago

      These two words mean the same thing, why would you be able ti picture one thing but not the other?

      • XIIIesq
        link
        -4
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        Try it, count grains of sand in your head whilst you picture them. Unless you’re a savant, it probably starts getting a little blurry around the teens, maybe a bit higher. You can use tricks like imagining a grid of ten by ten to picture a hundred etc, but it’ll still be rather blurry. Picturing a million of something is literally impossible, human minds aren’t designed for that.

        If you wanted some sand to line your new brick driveway, would you ask the builders merchant for a x tonnes of sand or a x million grains of sand? It’s the same difference.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          31 year ago

          By this logic, a millianything is also completely unimaginable, because you can’t count to less than one. BS.

          • XIIIesq
            link
            -31 year ago

            That’s the point, millis and megas make sense for things that aren’t tangible in real life. That’s exactly why we use tons and not megagrams.

            • @Shialac
              link
              11 year ago

              They literally are the same thing. Why would you imagine them differently?

              • XIIIesq
                link
                1
                edit-2
                1 year ago

                I’ve had this question quite a few times so I think that maybe I haven’t phrased my point of view so well.

                What I’m trying to say is that a million of anything is something the mind can’t comprehend. You can understand the idea of it, but you can’t mentally picture it.

                It makes sense to say “my car weighs about 2 tons”, because you can compare that to a couple of ton bags of sand or two IBCs of water.

                It doesn’t really make sense to say “my car weighs 2megagrams”, because not only will it not be be precisely 2,000,000 grams, but because no one can picture two million of anything.

                Despite the terms meaning the same thing, the mental imagery is totally different and it makes sense to use a unit that makes the description tangible in the real world.

        • @Shialac
          link
          21 year ago

          When I imagine 1km I don’t imagine 1000 individual meters in my head, I imagine 1km

          • XIIIesq
            link
            11 year ago

            The point is that you can easily estimate a meter.

            Look to the horizon and estimate a kilometre and I’ll bet that your error is significant by comparison to your estimate of a meter.

            There is a big difference between imagining/understanding a concept and judging it accurately in the real world.