• @[email protected]OP
    link
    fedilink
    31 year ago

    Is one carbon atom the same as another carbon atom, philosophically? Can you keep your identity when all your atoms are replaced by other atoms of the same kind? It’s the ship of Theseus problem

    • @yaaaaayPancakes
      link
      11 year ago

      I would think so. Our cellular machinery is constantly excreting waste made of atoms. Conversely, we eat food that gets broken down and used to create and repair cells. Are we all not ships of Theseus in that regard?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      11 year ago

      Irrelevant to the transporter as the same matter is moved by the matter stream and reassembled in the same order. This is less asking if the ship of Theseus is the same ship after the hull and the mast were replaced and more asking if my kitchen table is still the same after I took the leaf out, folded the legs in, put it in a truck, moved to a new house, and set it back up

    • Count Zero
      link
      fedilink
      English
      11 year ago

      Do you think you have the same skin cells as last week, yesterday, 20 minutes ago?

      Do you think the new cells come from the same carbon atoms?

      We’re already being disintegrated. It’s just a lot slower with imperfect replication. In fact, one could make the argument that that is a decent argument for life. Although it does include viruses and prions, so maybe not that far.