If you take a close look at the produce aisle of your grocery store, and look at the packaging instead of the vegetables and fruit, you’ll notice just how much plastic is in use.

Sliced mushrooms displayed on trays of polystyrene foam — a plastic now banned for use in takeout — and wrapped in plastic film, which soon won’t be collected in the blue box.

Peppers encased in clear plastic packaging, enticing you to pay less if you buy several.

“What they’re doing right now is just totally unsustainable from a waste perspective and from a plastics perspective,” says Karen Wirsig, plastics program manager for the Canadian organization Environmental Defence.

“If we’re trying to avoid food waste, then packaging things up and forcing me to buy 10 when I only need five is a terrible idea.”

Environmental Defence conducted an audit of 54 grocery stores across Canada — major grocery chains as well as independents — and found that 64 per cent of items in the produce, baby food, pet food and soup aisles were packaged in plastic. The group released its findings in April.

“The growth in this type of packaging works against the government goal to eliminate plastic waste by 2030,” according to the Environmental Defence report. “The increase in use of plastic packaging of all types also raises concerns about human — and particularly baby and toddler — exposure to chemical additives commonly found in plastic packaging, including phthalates and bisphenols.”

The federal government has banned some hard-to-recycle plastics used for takeout containers, as well as some other single-use plastics such as straws and ring carriers, as part of its goal to reach zero plastic waste by 2030. But aside from a ban on single-use plastic bags, there are no restrictions in grocery stores.

The government says it is “looking at the best way to manage the use of excess or unnecessary plastic packaging in grocery stores and will be publishing a discussion paper in the coming weeks for public comment,” according to an email from Environment and Climate Change Canada.

Canadians throw away three million tonnes — that is, three billion kilograms — of plastic waste every year, according to ECCC, and less than 10 per cent of it recycled.

Wirsig, who sits on a federal advisory committee looking at how to reduce plastic waste and pollution, says the government is considering a mandate of 50 per cent recycled content in plastic packaging, but may exempt food packaging because “it’s very difficult to get food-grade recycled plastic.”

Plastic, in general, can be difficult to recycle for a number of reasons.

Residential plastic waste is often contaminated by food, which devalues it because of the sorting that would be needed to remove the contaminated items. Plastic packaging can have numerous layers of materials, making it difficult to separate them for recycling. Canada lacks the physical infrastructure to scale up recycling. And environmentalists say that recycling plastic will release more chemicals and microplastics into the environment.

Environmental Defence has been pushing for reusable systems.

“Probably the most successful long-standing reuse and refill program that never has gone away is beer bottles,” says Wirsig, referring to the deposit return program at Ontario’s beer stores. “How could we adapt that to other things that come in jars? Or even cans with lids that can be resealed.”

One company that is trying to help producers reuse their packaging in grocery stores is Circulr, which offers a deposit system on glass jars used by more than 20 brands.

Consumers who return the jars to one of the company’s collection sites in Toronto, Kitchener-Waterloo, Guelph or Cambridge can reclaim a minimal deposit fee through an app. The company sanitizes the jars and returns them back to the same producers where possible, so that they can reuse them.

Circulr is working with a number of stores and brands, but has yet to scale up the program to put collection sites in one of the big grocery chains in Ontario, something that the company’s co-founder Charles Binks-Collier hopes to do this year.

Wirsig says grocery stores can be instrumental in reducing plastic packaging.

“They drive a lot of the packaging decisions. And they can drive that change too,” she says. “Certainly they should start with their own brands … But I think they need to also apply pressure” to other brands, she says.

“Loblaws was in a fight with Frito-Lay recently,” she says, noting a dispute over pricing between the grocery chain and the snack food producer that resulted in a shortage of the snack-maker’s wares on shelves for more than a month.

“You could have a fight about packaging.”

  • BaconIsAVeg
    link
    fedilink
    41 year ago

    Those statements conflict though. If the store buys thinner plastic bags to reduce costs, and more plastic is ending up in landfills as a result, then the store would have to be spending more on plastic bags.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      11 year ago

      Not really.

      Just throwing out some (completely made up) numbers, but let’s assume that there are two options:

      1. High-quality bags, where you only need one. $0.10 each.
      2. Super-cheap bags, which would require the customer to double up to be safe. $0.03 each.

      Using two super cheap bags would cost them $0.06 instead of $0.10. Hell, the customer could use three bags and still save them money, but with 3x more bags in the landfill with no chance to reuse them because of how shitty they are to begin with.

      I have no idea what the actual numbers are, but having been in an industry where these decisions come up, I’m confident that the hypothetical above is accurate to how they do things.

      And it’s not like I don’t appreciate the effort to save on material, like what Amazon has been doing with their boxes, but the use of these cheap bags isn’t doing anything but saving them money.

      • BaconIsAVeg
        link
        fedilink
        11 year ago

        Right, but the volume of plastic entering landfills would have to be less now. While I appreciate that someone buying a half dozen peaches or tomatoes might need to double bag, the main purpose of those bags (at least in my mind) is to keep the contents separate from the other shopping items.

        No one wants their lettuce brushing up against that box of laundry detergent, or their plastic wrapped chicken leaking all over a a loaf of bread.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          31 year ago

          I really hope that plastic entering landfills is down, I really do. I don’t want to use plastic bags, but since there are circumstances where I need to, I would rather reuse old grocery bags than buy new plastic bags.

          For produce, I’ve also used reusable mesh bags, which do work. The problem is that it takes resources to clean those and they arent cheap. I also cant reuse them for something like pet poop.